Home Case Laws GST penalty upheld as mismatch in e-way bill loading point confirmed through...

GST penalty upheld as mismatch in e-way bill loading point confirmed through GPS evidence and driver’s statement

0
387

Case Details

Case Title: M/s. Pratik Enterprises v. Principal Commissioner, CGST & Central Excise, Ranchi & Ors.
Court: High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi
Petition No.: W.P.(T) No. 3471 of 2025
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC) and Penalty under Detention of Goods
Date of Judgement: 25 July 2025
Relevant Sections: Section 16, Section 68(3), Section 129(1)(a) & (b) of the CGST Act, 2017; Rule 138 of the CGST Rules, 2017

Facts (Paras 1–6)

The petitioner, M/s Pratik Enterprises, challenged an order dated 17.03.2025 passed in Form GST MOV-09 under Section 129(3) of the CGST Act, imposing penalty of ₹3,43,075/-. The goods in transit were detained on 09.03.2025 as the loading point declared in the e-way bill differed from the actual loading point corroborated by the driver’s statement and GPS records. The department alleged the petitioner had availed huge ITC from suspicious/cancelled suppliers during FY 2023–24 and 2024–25, amounting to over ₹2 crore. The petitioner argued that all documents—e-invoice, e-way bill, consignment note, and weighment slip—were properly generated and carried.


Questions Before Court

  1. Whether penalty under Section 129(3) was sustainable when valid e-way bill and invoice were available?

  2. Whether discrepancy in loading point constituted violation of Rule 138 of CGST Rules?

  3. Whether the petitioner could claim refund of penalty amount paid for release of goods?


Observations (Paras 7–9)

The Court noted that though the e-way bill and invoice were generated, GPS data and driver’s statement revealed goods were loaded at Rupnarayanpur (West Medinipur) instead of the declared Sakui (Kharagpur). The vehicle halted for six hours at Rupnarayanpur on 08.03.2025, confirming the discrepancy. This amounted to a clear violation of Rule 138.

The Court emphasized that the petitioner had already deposited the penalty without protest to secure release of goods, which though not a waiver of rights, indicated that the adjudicating authority had strong material evidence against the petitioner.


Judgement (Paras 9–10)

The High Court held that the writ petition was an afterthought and devoid of merit since the discrepancy in loading point stood proven. Consequently, the penalty imposed under Section 129(3) was valid and enforceable. The petition was dismissed in limine.


Table of Cases Referred

Case Citation Verdict
No external precedents cited in this order – –

Between Fine Lines

For trade and industry, this judgment underscores that minor deviations in e-way bill particulars, such as incorrect loading point, can attract penalties under Section 129. Reliance on proper invoice and e-way bill generation alone will not suffice if supporting evidence like GPS data contradicts declared details. Businesses must ensure that the dispatch location in e-way bills matches the actual loading point to avoid detention and penalty.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY