Case Reference
Kaushlendra Kumar v. State of Bihar & Ors.
Patna High Court
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 17860 of 2024
Judgment Date: 01.05.2025
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC) denial & illegal recovery
Relevant Provisions: Sections 16(4), 16(5), 39, 73(5), 78 & 79 of CGST/BGST Act, 2017
Facts of the Case (Paras 3–6)
The petitioner, a works contractor for the Bihar Government, filed GSTR-3B belatedly for March 2020 on 07.12.2020 and claimed ITC of ₹48.91 lakh (CGST + SGST). A show cause notice was issued citing Section 16(4) time bar. Despite petitioner’s plea of Covid illness, the Assistant Commissioner demanded ₹55.64 lakh (tax, penalty, interest). Appeal before the Additional Commissioner was dismissed, holding no power to condone delay under Section 16(4).
Questions/Issues
-
Whether petitioner’s ITC claim, though belated, is saved by the retrospective insertion of Section 16(5) (Finance Act 2024).
-
Whether recovery of ₹50.75 lakh directly from petitioner’s employer within 28 days of appellate dismissal was legal under Sections 78 & 79.
Observations of the Court (Paras 10–27)
-
Section 16(5), inserted retrospectively from 01.07.2017, allows ITC for FY 2017-18 to FY 2020-21 if returns were filed up to 30.11.2021. This was not available to appellate authority earlier. Hence, matter deserves remand for fresh consideration (Paras 11–13).
-
Recovery provisions: Section 78 mandates 3 months’ waiting period after service of order before recovery. Section 79 provides modes of recovery but only after Section 78’s condition is met. Recovery before expiry of 3 months is unlawful unless reasons are recorded in writing (Paras 21–25).
-
Reliance placed on Sita Pandey v. State of Bihar (2023 SCC OnLine Pat 2827), which in turn relied on UTI Mutual Fund v. ITO (2012) 345 ITR 71 (Bom), laying guidelines that no recovery should be made within appeal/stay period (Paras 16, 28).
-
Court noted hasty recovery and deprecated revenue’s approach, quoting R.S. Joshi v. Ajit Mills (1977) 4 SCC 98, stressing quasi-judicial fairness (Para 26).
Judgment (Paras 29–35)
-
The appellate order and consequential recovery were set aside. Matter remanded to Appellate Authority to reconsider ITC in light of Section 16(5).
-
The recovery of ₹50,75,214/- from petitioner’s employer was declared illegal.
-
Respondents directed to refund the amount within two weeks, failing which 12% interest to apply.
-
Additionally, 6% interest awarded on the recovered sum from 02.01.2023 till refund, as the State cannot unjustly enrich itself (Para 33).
-
Apology of Assistant Commissioner accepted, costs not imposed.
Case Law Table
| Case | Court | Citation | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sita Pandey v. State of Bihar | Patna HC | (2023) SCC OnLine Pat 2827; 128 GSTR 137 | Recovery before 3 months without notice is illegal; refund with partial retention of 20% permitted for appeal. |
| UTI Mutual Fund v. ITO | Bombay HC | (2012) 345 ITR 71 | Guidelines issued: no recovery within appeal period; stay applications to be respected; recovery only with notice. |
| R.S. Joshi v. Ajit Mills | SC | (1977) 4 SCC 98 | Tax officers must act judicially, not merely as tax gatherers; mala fide recovery actions are void. |
| Mohinder Singh Gill v. CEC | SC | (1978) 1 SCC 405 | Fair hearing is a constitutional requirement; natural justice cannot be bypassed. |
Between Fine Lines
This judgment protects taxpayers against arbitrary and hasty recoveries by GST officers. Businesses now have judicial assurance that recovery cannot be made within three months of an order unless justified in writing, and retrospective relief under Section 16(5) ensures ITC rights are not denied unfairly. Contractors and suppliers to government departments can rely on this precedent to safeguard liquidity and claim timely refunds.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




