Home Case Laws Patna High Court upheld temporary ITC blocking under Rule 86A, holding that...

Patna High Court upheld temporary ITC blocking under Rule 86A, holding that reasons to believe were established through investigation, but directed taxpayer to seek remedy under CBIC guidelines for review.

0
281

Case Details

  • Case Title: M/s Graphic Trades Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Bihar & Ors.

  • Court: Patna High Court

  • Petition No.: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 4506 of 2025

  • Date of Judgment: 23 April 2025

  • Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajeev Ranjan Prasad & Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Pandey

  • Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC) – Blocking of ITC under Rule 86A

  • Relevant Sections / Rules:

    • Section 16, Section 49 of the CGST/BGST Act, 2017

    • Rule 86A of CGST/BGST Rules, 2017

    • Article 265, Constitution of India

Facts of the Case (Paras 2–7)

The petitioner, M/s Graphic Trades Pvt. Ltd., engaged in IT services, availed ITC of ₹1.18 crore from M/s TDML Services Pvt. Ltd.. A search by Kolkata CGST authorities found TDML non-existent at its principal place of business. Based on this, the Additional Commissioner (Respondent No. 3) instructed the Joint Commissioner (Respondent No. 4) to block petitioner’s ITC under Rule 86A. Petitioner challenged the order as arbitrary, lacking reasons to believe, and violative of Article 265. They relied on Samay Alloys (Gujarat HC) and Dee Vee Projects (Bombay HC), which emphasized mandatory recording of reasons before blocking ITC.


Questions Before Court

  1. Whether the blocking of ITC under Rule 86A without independent investigation and detailed reasoning is valid?

  2. Whether petitioner is entitled to unblocking of ITC on the ground of lack of due process and violation of natural justice?

  3. Whether remedy exists under CBIC guidelines post such blocking?


Observations of the Court (Paras 15–27)

  • The Court noted that materials such as the Kolkata CGST Anti-Evasion report and Alert Circular indicated TDML was non-existent and had passed fake ITC.

  • Rule 86A requires “reasons to believe” and recording of reasons. In Dee Vee Projects (Bombay HC), it was held this power is drastic, requiring objective satisfaction and fairness.

  • Unlike in Dee Vee Projects, where the blocking order was a mere two-liner, here the order was supported by Annexure P/2 and investigation reports, thus showing application of mind.

  • On natural justice, the Court held pre-decisional hearing is not mandated; however, post-decisional hearing is available under CBIC guidelines (para 3.4 of 2021 Guidelines).

  • The restriction is temporary (maximum one year), and petitioner has remedy to approach the authority for unblocking.


Judgment (Paras 28–31)

The Court upheld the impugned order as an interim measure under Rule 86A, finding no illegality or infirmity. It clarified that petitioner’s remedy lies in approaching the authority under CBIC guidelines for review. The writ petition was disposed of with liberty to the petitioner to seek remedy. Court did not enter into merits of ITC entitlement.


Table: Earlier Cases Referred

Case Court Ratio / Verdict
Samay Alloys India Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Gujarat (2022) Gujarat HC Held that Rule 86A blocking requires mandatory recording of reasons and cannot be mechanical.
Dee Vee Projects Ltd. v. Government of Maharashtra (2022) Bombay HC Declared that Rule 86A power is drastic; requires objective material, fairness, and post-decisional hearing.
Atulya Minerals v. Commissioner of State Tax (2024) Orissa HC Held that DIN system of Central tax does not apply to State tax unless adopted.

Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaway)

This judgment reiterates that ITC blocking under Rule 86A is permissible if backed by investigation and recorded reasons. Businesses must note that while courts may not quash interim blocking if supported by evidence, they can and should seek remedy before tax authorities under CBIC’s guidelines for unblocking within one year. Maintaining vendor due diligence remains crucial to avoid disputes over ITC fraud.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY