1. Title of the Case
| Case Title | M/s Groma Infrastructure Limited (formerly MVPR Infrastructure Limited), Raichur v. Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Commercial Taxes Department, Government of Karnataka |
| Case Number | Appeal No. APL/143/BUR/2026 (Appeal Case Reference No. Appeal/BUR/143/2026), against Order-in-Appeal No. GST: AP:445/2024-25 dated 19.02.2026 (Ref. ZD2902260984324) of the Joint Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Appeals), Kalaburagi, arising from Order-in-Original No. ACCT/Audit-4/KLB/2024-25 dated 13.08.2024 (Ref. ZD290824047815V) |
| Court and Bench | Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal, Bengaluru Bench, Division Bench – Court No. 3; Coram: Shri Prabhakaran P.M., Judicial Member, and Shri Ravi Jesuraj S., Technical Member (State) (order authored by the Technical Member for the Bench) |
| Date of Order | 06.10.2026 (pronounced in open Tribunal) |
| Relevant Provisions | Sections 13(2), 31(5), 50(1)-(2), 73(1) and (9), 75(6)-(7), 107(1), (4), (6), (8), (9) and (11), 112, 113(1) and 128A of the CGST Act, 2017 and the KGST Act, 2017; Rules 26, 35, 108 and 142(1A) of the CGST Rules, 2017; Notification No. 15/2021-Central Tax (Rate) dated 18.11.2021 (effective 01.01.2022); Order XXIX Rule 1, CPC, 1908 |
2. Summary of the Judgment
Facts of the Case: The appellant executes works contracts, such as lift-irrigation and electrical works, for Government undertakings in Karnataka (para 2). After the rate on works contracts supplied to a Government Entity rose from 12% to 18% on 01.01.2022, it paid differential tax of ₹1,32,90,600 under each of CGST and SGST through DRC-03 between October 2022 and June 2023 (para 63). Following an audit of 2021-22, the Order-in-Original dated 13.08.2024 dropped the ITC demand and confirmed interest alone of ₹44,46,989: ₹21,96,829 under each head on the differential tax, and CGST ₹27,841 and SGST ₹25,490 on cash paid late through GSTR-3B (paras 4, 7, 12-13). The first appeal, filed 21 days late with a condonation petition, was dismissed without a hearing for delay, want of the signatory’s authority and non-payment of an “admitted” amount (paras 14-17).
Issues for Determination: The Tribunal framed seven points (para 35): whether the appeal could be dismissed unheard; whether the delay should be condoned; whether the signatory held the company’s authority; whether Section 107(6) barred the appeal; whether the Tribunal should decide the merits; whether interest was payable on the differential tax and whether Rule 35 reduced it; and whether the GSTR-3B interest was within the notice and in what amount.
Findings and Observations of the Court: Section 107(8) is unqualified and applies equally to threshold objections; the dismissal breached it and natural justice (paras 37-38). A condonation petition was on record; neither the Act nor Rule 108 requires a separate application or affidavit, and the 21-day delay was condoned (paras 41-43). The General Manager held a notarised General Power of Attorney, and any gap in proof of authority was curable and ratified by the company’s conduct (paras 48-50). A computation made “even assuming” liability, while seeking relief from the whole, is not an admission; Section 107(6)(b) applies only to tax, and none was confirmed (paras 54-56). On merits, Section 50 interest is compensatory; the customer’s non-payment, hardship or retention money does not defer the time of supply, and Rule 35 cannot apply where tax was charged separately on a stated value (paras 62-72). Interest of ₹24,451 per head already paid had been ignored without reasons, contrary to Section 75(6) (paras 75-77).
Verdict and Basis of the Judgment: The appeal was partly allowed. The Order-in-Appeal was set aside, and, deciding the merits under Section 113(1), the Tribunal confirmed differential-tax interest and reduced GSTR-3B interest to CGST ₹418 and SGST ₹419. The demand stands at ₹43,94,495, interest alone (para 79).
Analysis of the Judgment: The ruling firmly protects appellants against summary dismissals on technical grounds, yet shows that procedural success does not carry the merits. By deciding the merits itself rather than remanding, the Tribunal avoided another round of litigation (paras 59-60).
Legal Takeaway: Alternative computations should be expressly qualified, and APL-01 should state the amount actually admitted. Contractors must pay tax when due regardless of customer default, recovering it contractually, and should document interest already paid for credit.
3. Tabular Summary
| Sl. No. | Case Title | Case No. / Citation | Court / Bench | Date of Order | Facts & Issue | Verdict & Basis of Judgment | Key Legal Takeaway |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | M/s Groma Infrastructure Ltd. (formerly MVPR Infrastructure Ltd.) v. Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Karnataka | APL/143/BUR/2026 (Appeal/BUR/143/2026); against OIA No. GST: AP:445/2024-25 dt. 19.02.2026 | GSTAT, Bengaluru Bench, DB – Court No. 3 (Prabhakaran P.M., JM; Ravi Jesuraj S., TM (State)) | 06.10.2026 | Works contractor paid 6% differential tax (12% to 18% from 01.01.2022) late via DRC-03; interest of ₹44,46,989 confirmed. First appeal, 21 days late, dismissed unheard for delay, signatory’s authority and unpaid “admitted” interest. Issues: validity of dismissal; liability to interest; Rule 35 cum-tax plea; credit for interest already paid. | Partly allowed. OIA set aside: breach of S. 107(8); delay condoned; GPA holder validly signed; “even assuming” computation not an admission; no pre-deposit where no tax confirmed. Merits decided under S. 113(1): S. 50 interest of ₹21,96,829 per head confirmed; Rule 35 rejected; GSTR-3B interest cut to ₹418/₹419. Demand ₹43,94,495. | Appellate Authority must hear before dismissing even on threshold grounds. Only clear, unequivocal admissions trigger S. 107(6)(a). Customer default or retention money does not defer GST or interest; claims of interest paid must be considered. |
Download the judgment: Download PDF




