1. Title of the Case
| Case Title | M/s Navitas Eduservices Private Limited v. Commissioner of CGST, South Delhi (with the connected Revenue appeal, Commissioner of CGST, South Delhi v. M/s Navitas Eduservices Private Limited) |
| Case Number | Appeal Nos. APL/23/PB/2026 (lead appeal), APL/33/PB/2026, APL/37/PB/2026, APL/38/PB/2026 and APL/89/PB/2026 (filed by the taxpayer in Form APL-05) and Appeal No. APL/13/PB/2026 (filed by the Revenue in Form APL-07); common Final Order |
| Court and Bench | GST Appellate Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (Division Bench, Court No. 1); Coram: Hon’ble Justice (Retd.) Dr. Sanjaya Kumar Mishra, President, and Hon’ble Sh. Anil Kumar Gupta, Member (Technical) |
| Date of Order | 14.10.2026 (pronounced in open court) |
| Relevant Provisions | Sections 2(6), 2(13), 13(2), 13(3)(b) and 13(8)(b) (since omitted by the Finance Act, 2026) and Section 16 of the IGST Act, 2017; Sections 54, 54(8), 56, 107(11), 112 and 113(1) of the CGST Act, 2017; Rules 89 and 110 of the CGST Rules, 2017; CBIC Circular No. 159/15/2021-GST |
2. Summary of the Judgment
Facts of the Case. The appellant, a wholly owned subsidiary of Navitas Pty Limited, Australia, renders marketing support and IT-enabled services to its Australian parent under a Master Services Agreement dated 07.12.2016, on a cost plus 16% basis, paid in Australian Dollars (paras 5, 8, 10 and 20). Clauses 5.1 and 5.2 deny any agency. Recruitment advisors are engaged on commission directly by Navitas Australia (paras 9 and 21). Its refund claims of unutilised ITC on export of services for periods between 2018 and 2023 were rejected as intermediary services. The First Appellate Authority upheld the rejections, save in one matter where it annulled the order and directed reconsideration, which the Revenue challenged (paras 3, 13 and 17).
Issues for Determination. The Tribunal framed two questions: whether the services qualify as export of services under Section 2(6) of the IGST Act or are intermediary services under Section 2(13); and whether an order annulling the original order and directing the proper officer to reconsider is, in substance, a remand barred by law (para 1).
Findings and Observations of the Court. The objection on differing entity names was rejected, as it arose from the company’s reconstitution (para 27). Relying on Genpact India (P&H HC), Columbia Sportswear (Karnataka HC), Blackberry India (Delhi HC), its own decision in Dow Chemical and Circular No. 159/15/2021-GST, it held that an intermediary requires three parties, two distinct supplies and the character of a broker or agent; that “any other person” must be read ejusdem generis; and that a sub-contractor supplying on its own account is excluded (paras 30 to 34). Following FATEH Education Consulting (Delhi HC), it declined to rely on Advance Rulings, which are not courts of record (paras 35 and 36). On the Revenue’s appeal, it held that Section 107(11) expressly bars remand and cannot be circumvented by a “jugglery of words”; only the Tribunal may remand under Section 113(1) (paras 38 and 39).
Verdict and Basis of the Judgment. The five taxpayer appeals were allowed, the impugned orders set aside and refund of unutilised ITC directed with interest at the rates of six and nine per cent specified in the order, from the dates tabulated in para 37. The Revenue’s appeal was allowed to that extent and the matter remitted to the First Appellate Authority for a decision on merits, preferably within six weeks (paras 39 and 40).
Analysis of the Judgment. The decision aligns with the consistent High Court view that cost-plus support services rendered on a principal-to-principal basis are not intermediary services merely because they further the foreign recipient’s business with third parties. It also reaffirms that a Section 107 appellate authority must decide on merits and cannot disguise a remand as an annulment.
Legal Takeaway. Indian subsidiaries supplying marketing, recruitment-support or IT services to overseas group entities should document bipartite contracts, cost-plus remuneration, absence of agency and no privity with end customers. Taxpayers facing remand-style orders from the First Appellate Authority may challenge them as contrary to Section 107(11).
3. Tabular Summary
| Sl. No. | Case Title | Case No. / Citation | Court / Bench | Date of Order | Facts & Issue | Verdict & Basis of Judgment | Key Legal Takeaway |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | M/s Navitas Eduservices Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of CGST, South Delhi (with connected Revenue appeal) | APL/23/PB/2026 (lead), APL/33, 37, 38, 89/PB/2026 and Revenue’s APL/13/PB/2026; common Final Order | GSTAT, Principal Bench, New Delhi | 14.10.2026 | Refund of unutilised ITC on marketing and IT support services supplied to the Australian parent on cost-plus basis was denied as intermediary services. Issues: export or intermediary under Sections 2(6) and 2(13) IGST Act; whether annulment with direction to reconsider is a barred remand. | Taxpayer appeals allowed; refund with interest directed. Services rendered on own account as sub-contractor; no three-party arrangement or agency; Circular 159/15/2021-GST and High Court rulings followed; AAR rulings not followed. Revenue appeal allowed to the extent that the remand-type order violated Section 107(11); matter remitted to the First Appellate Authority. | Cost-plus, principal-to-principal support services to a foreign group entity are export of services, not intermediary. The First Appellate Authority cannot remand under any label; only the Tribunal may remand under Section 113(1). |
Download the judgment: Download judgement.




