Home Case Laws Gujarat High Court Stays Compensation Cess Demand on Exports Pending GST Council...

Gujarat High Court Stays Compensation Cess Demand on Exports Pending GST Council Review

0
384

Case Reference

  • Case Title: M/s. Sopariwala Export Pvt. Ltd. v. Joint Commissioner, CGST and Central Excise & Ors.

  • Court: High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad

  • Petition Nos.: R/Special Civil Application No. 6701 of 2023, 7073 of 2023, 15708 of 2024

  • Category: Levy of Compensation Cess on Export via Merchant Exporters

  • Date of Judgement: 09/05/2025

  • Relevant Sections: Section 8, 11 of Compensation Cess Act, Section 54(3), 74, 122(2)(b), CGST Act, Section 2(5), 16 of IGST Act, Rule 28 of CGST Rules


Facts of the Case (¶6–¶36)

  • The petitioner, a manufacturer of branded tobacco (HSN 24039910), exported goods via merchant exporters.

  • Under Notifications No. 40/2017 and 41/2017 dated 23.10.2017, GST was charged at 0.1% on such exports.

  • Compensation Cess at 160% was not levied based on the understanding that it applied only to domestic supplies.

  • DGGI initiated an investigation and issued SCN alleging suppression and demanded Compensation Cess of ₹18.63 crores (¶28–¶35).

  • The petitioner argued that such exports are zero-rated and levy of cess would be revenue-neutral (¶31, ¶59–¶61).


Question(s) in Consideration (¶94)

  • Whether Compensation Cess at 160% is applicable on supplies of tobacco to merchant exporters for export?

  • Can Notification Nos. 40/2017 & 41/2017 be interpreted to extend to Compensation Cess?

  • Does the absence of a specific exemption notification under the Compensation Cess Act invalidate exemption benefits?


Observations of the Court

  1. Nature of Supply as Export (¶97–¶99, ¶111–¶114):

    • Supplies made by the petitioner to merchant exporters qualify as “export” under Section 2(5) of the IGST Act.

    • These are zero-rated supplies under Section 16 and eligible for refund.

  2. Revenue Neutrality (¶100–¶107):

    • Levying Compensation Cess at 160% only to refund it later defeats the purpose and leads to working capital blockage.

  3. Role of GST Council (¶101–¶106, ¶115–¶117):

    • GST Council had intended to minimize tax impact on merchant exporters by recommending a nominal 0.1% rate.

    • Though no separate Notification was issued for Compensation Cess, provisions of Section 11 of Compensation Cess Act mandate mutatis mutandis application of GST provisions.

  4. Exemption Must Extend to Compensation Cess (¶105–¶106):

    • Court held that the exemption given under GST must extend to Compensation Cess to maintain legislative harmony and to avoid arbitrary discrimination.

  5. Violation of Natural Justice and Absence of Suppression (¶71–¶74):

    • The petitioner declared all details in GST returns; therefore, no suppression or wilful default exists under Section 74 of CGST Act.


Judgment of the Court (¶116–¶120)

  • The impugned orders levying ₹18.63 crores of Compensation Cess are kept in abeyance.

  • Matter referred to GST Council to consider a recommendation to exempt Compensation Cess on such exports, in line with 0.1% GST rate on merchant exporter supplies.

  • Till such recommendation, no coercive action, show cause notice, or adjudication should be taken if petitioners submit an undertaking.

  • The GST Council is urged to address the anomaly promptly.


🧾 Between Fine Lines

  • The Gujarat High Court has paused the levy of 160% Compensation Cess on exports made via merchant exporters.

  • The court emphasized that such supplies qualify as exports and are zero-rated, hence not liable to Compensation Cess.

  • Revenue neutrality and GST Council’s original intention to avoid fund blockage were key to the ruling.

  • Petitioners cannot be penalized when all statutory procedures were followed and no suppression occurred.

  • The ball is now in GST Council’s court to issue clarificatory exemption for Compensation Cess.


Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict Impact
Amritsar Sugar Mills Co. Ltd. AIR 1966 SC 1242 Held “constructive delivery” can qualify as export Applied to define exports
Lord Krishna Sugar Mills (1966) 18 STC 498 (SC) Reaffirmed concept of indirect export as actual export Applied
Coca-Cola India Pvt. Ltd. 2007 (213) ELT 490 (SC) Revenue neutrality principle established Applied
Mohit Minerals 2022 (61) GSTL 257 (SC) Compensation Cess is a tax on supply under Article 246A Applied
Unicorn Industries 2019 (370) ELT 3 (SC) Excise exemption not automatically applicable to NCCD/cess Distinguished
Star Industries Ltd. 2015 (324) ELT 656 (SC) Strict construction of exemption notifications Distinguished
Budhan Chaudhry v. State of Bihar AIR 1955 SC 191 Article 14 permits classification if reasonable Applied for constitutional argument
VKC Footsteps India Pvt. Ltd. (2022) 2 SCC 603 Courts can’t redraft formula, urged GST Council for reconsideration Followed to suggest Council review

LEAVE A REPLY