The Delhi Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal in Hero Fincorp Limited v. DCIT, Circle 10(1), Delhi has granted substantial relief to the assessee by deleting an addition of approximately ₹168.31 crore under Section 56(2)(viib) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The Tribunal also deleted the disallowance sustained under Section 14A, holding that the statutory requirement of recording satisfaction regarding the assessee’s computation had not been fulfilled.
Section 14A: Satisfaction of Assessing Officer is Mandatory
During the relevant year, Hero Fincorp earned exempt dividend income of ₹1,16,450 and made a suo motu disallowance of ₹910 under Section 14A read with Rule 8D. The Assessing Officer, however, computed a substantially higher disallowance of ₹56,97,807, which was subsequently restricted by the CIT(A) to the amount of exempt income, namely ₹1,16,450.
The Tribunal observed that the Assessing Officer had not expressly recorded dissatisfaction regarding the correctness of the assessee’s suo motu disallowance after examining its accounts. Following the principles laid down by the Delhi High Court, including in PCIT v. UK Paints India Pvt. Ltd. and Coforge Ltd. v. ACIT, the ITAT held that recourse to Rule 8D could not be taken merely because the Assessing Officer preferred a different computation.
Accordingly, the disallowance of ₹1,16,450 sustained by the CIT(A) was deleted.
Section 56(2)(viib): DCF Valuation Cannot Be Rejected Merely on Subsequent Actual Results
The more significant controversy concerned an addition of ₹168,30,67,669.50 under Section 56(2)(viib).
Hero Fincorp had obtained a valuation report dated 16 August 2016 adopting the Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) method. It subsequently issued 57,65,905 share warrants at a face value of ₹10 each with a premium of ₹510.30 per warrant. The warrants were convertible into an equal number of equity shares within 18 months.
The Assessing Officer rejected the DCF valuation primarily after comparing the projected turnover and profitability with the actual financial results subsequently achieved. He instead adopted the Net Asset Value (NAV) method, arriving at a value of ₹228.41 per share, and treated the difference as excessive share premium taxable under Section 56(2)(viib).
Valuation Must Be Judged on Information Available on Valuation Date
The ITAT disagreed with the approach adopted by the tax authorities. It emphasised that a DCF valuation necessarily involves future estimates and projections. Its validity has to be examined with reference to the information and circumstances existing on the valuation date, rather than simply by comparing projections with actual results that emerge later.
The Tribunal relied upon judicial principles recognising that valuation is not an exact science and that an expert valuation cannot be discarded merely because subsequent commercial results differ from projections. Specific errors in the underlying data, assumptions or methodology must be established before rejecting an expert valuation.
The Tribunal also noted that the assessee’s historical figures demonstrated substantial growth in revenue, profits and its asset book. Therefore, the projections used for valuation could not simply be characterised as exorbitant or aggressive.
Later Performance Also Undermined Revenue’s Reasoning
An important factual aspect noticed by the ITAT was that the Assessing Officer had substantially relied upon the results for the year ending March 2018. However, subsequent performance showed that in certain later years the assessee’s actual growth was even higher than the growth projected under the DCF valuation.
According to the Tribunal, considering only one year’s variance did not present the correct position. The Revenue’s approach of rejecting the DCF valuation merely on the basis of a comparison between projections and subsequent actual figures was therefore found to be unsustainable on the facts of the case.
₹168.31 Crore Addition Deleted
Considering the overall facts and the judicial principles governing valuation, the ITAT held that the CIT(A) was not justified in sustaining the addition. It therefore reversed the appellate order and directed deletion of the entire addition of ₹168,30,67,669.50 made under Section 56(2)(viib).
The assessee’s appeal was consequently allowed on both issues—the Section 14A disallowance as well as the Section 56(2)(viib) share valuation addition.
Key Takeaway
The ruling reiterates two important principles of income-tax law. First, the Assessing Officer must record the requisite satisfaction regarding the incorrectness of an assessee’s Section 14A computation before invoking Rule 8D. Secondly, a DCF valuation cannot ordinarily be rejected merely because subsequent actual financial performance differs from projections. A valuation based on recognised methodology must be examined in light of information available at the time it was prepared and cannot be displaced without identifying material defects in its assumptions or data.




