Home Case Laws IGST not leviable on component of ocean freight paid by foreign seller...

IGST not leviable on component of ocean freight paid by foreign seller to foreign shipping line

0
543

Case Title: Union of India v. Mohit Minerals Pvt. Ltd.

Court Name: Supreme Court of India

Petition Number: Civil Appeal Nos. 1390, 1394 of 2022 and others

Category: Reverse Charge Mechanism – Ocean Freight

Date of Judgement: 19 May 2022

Relevant Sections:

 

Section 5(1), 5(3), 5(4), 7(4), 13(9) of the IGST Act

Sections 2(93), 2(98), 2(31), 15, 24(iii) of the CGST Act

Notifications 8/2017 and 10/2017-Integrated Tax (Rate)

 

Facts of the Case (Paras 1–9)

  • Mohit Minerals Pvt. Ltd., an importer of coal under CIF (Cost, Insurance, Freight) contracts, challenged the levy of IGST on ocean freight under reverse charge on the importer when the freight was paid by the foreign supplier to a foreign shipping line.
  • The Gujarat High Court declared Notification No. 8/2017 and 10/2017 ultra vires the IGST Act, as it imposed a reverse charge IGST on the importer for ocean freight, even though the service was provided by and to non-taxable territory entities and was already included in the value of imported goods for customs duty purposes (Para 1–6).
  • Union of India appealed, asserting the levy was constitutionally valid and intended to remove disparities between Indian and foreign shipping lines (Para 7–9).

 

Question(s) in Consideration (Paras 95–97)

  1. Whether the importer under a CIF contract can be considered a ‘recipient’ of shipping services under section 2(93) of the CGST Act and thus liable under reverse charge.
  2. Whether the impugned notifications were ultra vires the IGST/CGST Act, leading to double taxation and violating territorial nexus.
  3. Whether Parliament had delegated excessive legislative power by allowing the government to fix such levy by notification.

Observations of the Court

  1. On Nature of Supply and Recipient: The court held that under section 13(9) of the IGST Act, the place of supply for transport services is the destination of goods, i.e., India. Thus, the importer can be construed as the recipient of services under section 2(93)(c) of the CGST Act, despite not directly contracting or paying for it (Paras 103–105, 118–119).
  2. On Delegated Legislation: The court found that Section 5(3) of the IGST Act allows the government to specify categories of supply subject to reverse charge, but not the person liable. Thus, the power to deem the importer as the recipient under Notification 10/2017 exceeded the parent statute (Paras 64–66, 85–86).
  3. On Double Taxation: The court acknowledged that IGST was already being levied on the CIF value (which includes ocean freight) at the time of customs clearance. Imposing IGST again on the freight component resulted in double taxation, which is impermissible (Paras 6, 123).
  4. On Extra-Territoriality: Although Parliament can legislate with respect to extra-territorial aspects with nexus to India (GVK Industries v. ITO), in this case, there was no such statutory deeming fiction to treat such services as import of services under IGST Act (Paras 106–110).
  5. On Binding Nature of GST Council: The court clarified that recommendations of the GST Council are not binding on Parliament or the States. Article 279A establishes the Council as a collaborative federal mechanism; it does not override legislative supremacy (Paras 43–51).

Judgement of the Court (Paras 127–129)

  • The Supreme Court upheld the Gujarat High Court’s view and held that the impugned Notifications 8/2017 and 10/2017 were ultra vires the IGST Act.
  • The court declared that in a CIF contract, the importer cannot be considered the recipient of shipping services, and thus, IGST cannot be levied under reverse charge on ocean freight in such cases.
  • The levy results in double taxation and violates statutory scheme and constitutional mandate (Paras 122–123).

 

Between Fine Lines:

  1. Importers under CIF contracts are not liable for IGST on ocean freight under reverse charge.
  2. The impugned notifications exceeded the legal scope of the IGST Act.
  3. The judgment upholds the principle that delegated legislation cannot override parent statutes.
  4. GST Council recommendations are not binding; States retain legislative autonomy.
  5. Double taxation on the same freight component is impermissible.

 

Summary of Referred Cases:

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Mathuram Agrawal v. State of MP (1999) 8 SCC 667 Laid down essential components of a valid tax law Applied
Gobind Saran Ganga Saran v. CST AIR 1985 SC 1041 Tax must identify event, person, rate, and measure Applied
GVK Industries v. ITO (2011) 332 ITR 130 (SC) Parliament can legislate extraterritorially with nexus Distinguished
Laghu Udyog Bharati v. UOI (1999) 105 Taxman 630 (SC) Reverse charge must be explicitly provided by statute Applied
BSNL v. UOI (2006) 282 ITR 273 (SC) Double taxation not permissible without legislative clarity Applied
Union of India v. VKC Footsteps India (P) Ltd. (2021) 130 taxmann.com 193 GST Council’s recommendations are not binding Followed
Electronic Corpn. of India v. CIT 1989 Supp 2 SCC 642 Territorial nexus in tax laws upheld Applied
McDowell & Co. v. CTO (1985) 3 SCC 230 Aspect theory permits different levies on same transaction Discussed
Ispat Industries Ltd. v. CCE (2006) taxmann.com 285 (SC) Ocean freight in CIF is part of customs value Applied

 

Download Judgement

LEAVE A REPLY