Home Case Laws Actionable claim are included in the category of ‘goods’

Actionable claim are included in the category of ‘goods’

0
731

Case Title: Skill Lotto Solutions (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India

Court: Supreme Court of India

Petition No.: Writ Petition (Civil) No. 961 of 2018

Category: Classification, Levy of GST on Lottery, Constitutional Validity

Date of Judgment: 3 December 2020

Relevant Provisions: Section 2(52), Section 15 of the CGST Act, Rule 31A of CGST Rules, Article 246A, 14, 19(1)(g), 301, 304 of Constitution

 

Facts of the Case [Paras 2 to 5]

  • The petitioner, an authorised lottery distributor for the State of Punjab, challenged the inclusion of lotteries within the definition of “goods” under Section 2(52) of the CGST Act, 2017.
  • The petitioner alleged that taxing lottery tickets as “goods” violates Articles 14, 19(1)(g), 301, and 304 of the Constitution as it is discriminatory, especially since only three actionable claims (lottery, betting, gambling) are taxed.
  • It was also argued that the GST is levied on the full face value of the lottery ticket, including prize money that does not accrue to the distributor.
  • The petitioner sought a declaration that the levy was ultra vires, discriminatory and sought refund/adjustment against the taxable base excluding prize money.

 

Questions in Consideration [Para 12]

  1. Is the writ petition maintainable under Article 32 given the claim relates to lottery—a res extra commercium?
  2. Is the inclusion of “actionable claim” in “goods” under Section 2(52) unconstitutional?
  3. Was the judgment in Sunrise Associates holding lottery as an actionable claim ratio decidendi or obiter?
  4. Is excluding only lottery, betting, and gambling from Schedule III of CGST Act discriminatory under Article 14?
  5. Should prize money be excluded from the face value of the ticket for calculating GST?

 

Observations of the Court

  • On Maintainability [Paras 13–17]:
    Despite lottery being res extra commercium, the Court held the petition maintainable under Article 32 due to allegations of Article 14 violation in a parliamentary law.
  • On Constitutional Validity of Section 2(52) [Paras 18–62]:
    The definition of “goods” under CGST Act includes actionable claims, which is consistent with Sunrise Associates, where the Constitution Bench held lottery to be an actionable claim [Para 48].
    The Court rejected reliance on Gannon Dunkerley as the issue there related to “sale” and not the expanded legislative competence under Article 246A [Para 35–37].
    It held the inclusive definition was constitutionally valid [Paras 49, 61].
  • On Discrimination under Article 14 [Paras 63–71]:
    The Court noted lottery, betting, and gambling have historically been regulated/taxed and treated as morally and economically distinct.
    Their exclusion from Schedule III is rational and not arbitrary. No violation of Article 14 was found [Para 70–71].
  • On Exclusion of Prize Money from Taxable Value [Paras 72–82]:
    Section 15 and Rule 31A govern valuation. Rule 31A deems value of supply to be 100/128 of ticket face value.
    The Court upheld this deeming fiction, rejecting arguments for excluding prize money.
    GST valuation is a matter of legislative policy, not judicial determination.

 

Judgment of the Court [Para 82–83]

  • The writ petition was dismissed.
  • The Court upheld the inclusion of actionable claims in the definition of “goods” under Section 2(52) CGST Act, 2017.
  • There was no hostile discrimination in taxing only lotteries, betting and gambling.
  • The Court granted liberty to the petitioner to challenge subsequent notifications dated 21-2-2020/02-3-2020 separately.

 

Between Fine Lines

  • The Supreme Court upheld that lotteries are actionable claims and can be taxed under GST.
  • Taxing only lottery, betting, and gambling is not discriminatory due to their special historical and regulatory treatment.
  • Prize money is not deductible from ticket value when computing GST; value is deemed under statutory formula.
  • The challenge on grounds of unconstitutionality, discrimination, and irrational tax base was rejected.
  • Liberty was granted to challenge subsequent notifications on uniform GST rate later.

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Sunrise Associates v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi (2006) 4 STT 105 (SC) Held lottery is an actionable claim and not “goods” under sales tax laws. Upheld and followed; treated as ratio.
State of Madras v. Gannon Dunkerley & Co. [1959] SCR 379 “Sale of goods” in Entry 54 interpreted to mean transfer of property in goods, not applicable to works contract. Distinguished; not applicable post Article 246A.
R.M.D. Chamarbaugwala v. State of Bombay AIR 1957 SC 699 Held gambling and lottery are res extra commercium and not protected under Article 19(1)(g). Followed to support classification.
Reserve Bank v. Peerless General Finance [1987] 1 SCC 424 Discussed inclusive definitions to expand scope of words. Applied to support inclusion of actionable claims.
Navinchandra Mafatlal v. CIT AIR 1955 SC 58 Parliament has wide power to define taxable income. Applied to validate legislative discretion.
Bhopal Sugar Industries Ltd. v. D.P. Dube [1964] 1 SCR 481 Extended definition of “sale” beyond legislative competence. Distinguished; not applicable to GST’s deeming fiction.

 

Download Judgement

LEAVE A REPLY