Veer Pratap Singh v. State of Kerala
High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No. 22016 of 2020 (B)
Date of Judgement: 6 November 2020
Category of Dispute: Detention and Confiscation of Goods under GST
Relevant Sections: Section 129(3) and Section 130 of CGST Act, 2017
Facts of the Case
- The petitioners are traders in brass and copper scrap, operating from Coimbatore (Tamil Nadu) and Jamnagar (Gujarat). A consignment of scrap being transported from Coimbatore to Gujarat was detained at Kodumuda, Palakkad (Kerala) by GST officials. [¶1]
- The detention was on grounds of discrepancies in accompanying documents—specifically, doubts regarding the place of origin of the goods, which was allegedly Palakkad, not Coimbatore as declared. [¶1]
- Despite having a valid e-way bill and invoice showing payment of IGST, the department proceeded to issue a FORM GST MOV-10 notice under Section 130 of the CGST Act for confiscation, alleging intent to evade tax. [¶1]
- Petitioners submitted replies and attended hearings, but their contentions were rejected, resulting in a confiscation order of goods and the vehicle. [¶1]
Question(s) in Consideration
- Whether invoking Section 130 of the CGST Act and passing a confiscation order was legally sustainable when there was no material to establish intention to evade tax. [¶4]
- Whether the department could instead proceed under Section 129 of the CGST Act in the absence of mala fide intent. [¶4]
Observation of Court
- The Court observed that while the initial detention under Section 129 was justified based on the discrepancy in the place of origin, the material on record did not establish any intent to evade tax. [¶4]
- The Court emphasized that the payment of IGST was admitted by the petitioner and the goods were destined for Gujarat, thus tax jurisdiction and liability would remain the same. [¶4]
- The confiscation under Section 130 requires specific evidence of intention to evade tax, which was absent here. There was no assertion in the MOV-10 notice about any specific act indicating tax evasion. [¶4]
Judgement of the Court
- The High Court quashed the confiscation order passed under Section 130, holding it unsustainable in law. [¶4]
- The respondents were directed to instead proceed under Section 129(3) after giving the petitioners an opportunity of being heard. [¶4]
- The petitioners were allowed to release the goods and vehicle on furnishing a bank guarantee equivalent to the tax and penalty determined. [¶4]
- The bank guarantee was to remain uninvoked for three weeks post communication of the order under Section 129(3), to allow the petitioners time to appeal. [¶4]
Between Fine Lines
- The Court reiterated that mere documentary discrepancy, absent any intention to evade tax, does not justify confiscation under Section 130.
- It distinguished between procedural lapses and tax evasion, safeguarding taxpayers from excessive penal consequences.
- Payment of IGST and consistent destination declarations negated mala fide intent.
- The ruling ensures procedural fairness and due opportunity before final confiscatory action.
- The decision acts as a restraint against misuse of confiscation powers in goods-in-transit cases.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| No specific case cited in the judgment | – | The decision was rendered primarily on facts and interpretation of Sections 129 and 130 without reference to prior case law. | – |




