Home Case Laws Issuing orders without hearing violates principal of Natural Justice and the same...

Issuing orders without hearing violates principal of Natural Justice and the same are liable to be quashed.

0
591

Case Title: Damodar Corporation v. Union of India

Court: High Court of Kerala

Petition Number: W.P. (C) No. 18308 of 2020 (K)

Category of Dispute: Natural Justice – Personal Hearing

Date of Judgement: November 12, 2020

Relevant Section: Article 226 of the Constitution of India; Principles of Natural Justice under GST

Takeaway: Hearing Denied, Justice Denied – Revisiting GST Orders Without Audi Alteram Partem

 

Facts of the Case [¶1]:

  • Damodar Corporation filed a writ petition challenging a series of orders (Ext. P14) passed under the GST Act.
  • The core grievance was that the impugned orders were passed without affording the petitioner a proper opportunity of being heard.
  • Although notices were issued and a reply was submitted with a request for adjournment, the final orders were passed without granting a further opportunity for a personal hearing.

 

Question(s) in Consideration [¶1–2]:

  1. Whether the Ext.P14 series of orders passed under the GST Act are legally sustainable when passed without granting the petitioner a reasonable opportunity for a personal hearing.
  2. Whether such orders violate principles of natural justice and procedural fairness under the GST regime.

 

Observation of Court [¶2]:

  • The High Court found that there was a clear violation of natural justice, as the petitioner was not granted a hearing before finalizing the orders.
  • The officer acted without accommodating the adjournment sought by the petitioner, resulting in non-compliance with mandatory procedural safeguards.

 

Judgement of the Court [¶2]:

  • The Court quashed the Ext.P14 orders for being passed in violation of natural justice.
  • Directed the 7th respondent (Proper Officer) to pass fresh orders after granting a personal hearing and considering both jurisdictional and substantive objections.
  • Ordered the petitioner to appear before the officer (physically or virtually) on 27-11-2020 at 11 a.m.
  • Mandated that revised orders be passed within 3 months of receiving the judgment.

 

Between Fine Lines:

  • GST orders must follow the principle of “audi alteram partem” (hear the other side).
  • Procedural fairness is not a formality but a mandatory safeguard.
  • Even if replies are received, lack of hearing renders the decision void.
  • Courts can direct reconsideration if natural justice is breached.
  • Taxpayers should be vigilant in asserting their right to a hearing under GST laws.

 

Summary of Referred Cases:

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
None specifically cited in the judgment – The case did not refer to external precedents; it was adjudicated on fundamental principles of natural justice and procedural impropriety. –

LEAVE A REPLY