Case Title: Sanjiv Kumar Mittal v. Deputy Commissioner (TRC)
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition No.: W.P. (C) No. 5590/2020, CM Appl. No. 20200/2020
Category of Dispute: Recovery under Finance Act – Director’s personal liability
Date of Judgement: 06 November 2020
Relevant Sections:
Section 87(b)(i) of the Finance Act, 1994
Section 174(1), 174(2)(e) of CGST Act, 2017
Section 9AA of Central Excise Act, 1944
Section 168(2) of Companies Act, 2013
Facts of the Case
[¶1-5]
- The petitioner was an Additional Director of M/s Unickon Real Estate Pvt. Ltd. from 22.08.2014 to 08.07.2015.
- The company was already under Service Tax investigation before his appointment.
- A show cause notice and subsequent Order-in-Original dated 08.08.2018 confirmed tax dues on the company.
- Recovery notices and an attachment order (08.06.2020) were issued against the petitioner’s personal bank account under Section 87(b)(i) of the Finance Act.
Questions in Consideration
[¶8-10, 13-14, 18, 22-24]
- Can a former Director be held personally liable for dues of the company under the Finance Act, 1994?
- Is section 87(b)(i) applicable to attach a Director’s personal bank account for recovery from a company?
- Were principles of natural justice followed before issuing recovery and attachment notices?
Observation of the Court
[¶20-25, 28-31]
- A company is a separate juristic entity; its Directors are not personally liable unless a specific statutory provision or evidence of fraud/misfeasance exists.
- Section 87(b)(i) is a garnishee provision for attaching funds of the assessee (company) lying with third parties—not meant for attaching personal funds of ex-Directors.
- There is no statutory provision under the Finance Act holding Directors liable for company dues.
- Provisions such as Section 9AA (Central Excise) and Section 168(2) (Companies Act) deal with penal offences, not civil tax liabilities.
- No show cause notice or hearing was given to the petitioner individually, violating natural justice.
Judgement of the Court
[¶33]
- The writ petition was allowed.
- Demand notices dated 21.05.2019 and 08.11.2019, and the attachment order dated 08.06.2020, were quashed.
- Any consequential actions taken against the petitioner based on these notices or the Order-in-Original were also set aside.
Between Fine Lines
- A Director cannot be held personally liable for a company’s tax dues unless the statute explicitly provides so.
- Attachment under Section 87(b)(i) is limited to garnishee action, not against a Director’s personal account.
- Personal liability must be established through proper notice and hearing.
- The distinction between the company and its Directors is vital and cannot be overridden lightly.
- Courts uphold natural justice before invoking drastic recovery measures.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Mrs. Bacha F. Guzdar v. CIT | AIR 1955 SC 74 | Affirmed the principle that a company is a separate legal entity distinct from its shareholders/directors. | Company is distinct; limited liability upheld. |
| Sunil Parmeshwar Mittal v. Dy. Commr. | 2005 (4) Mah LJ 837 | Former Directors not liable for company’s tax dues unless a specific statutory provision exists. | Recovery from ex-Director set aside. |
Takeaway
“When Distinct Entities Collide: Directors Can’t Be Garnished for Company’s Dues Without Lawful Backing”




