Home Case Laws ITC demand order quashed as reversal was already made; court holds fresh...

ITC demand order quashed as reversal was already made; court holds fresh adjudication must focus only on interest and penalty for delayed reversal

0
415

Case Summary

Case Title: Ajay Industries v. Union of India
Court: High Court of Gujarat, Ahmedabad
Petition No.: R/Special Civil Application No. 2951 of 2025
Judgment Date: 16 April 2025
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC) reversal, Show Cause Notice, Natural Justice
Relevant Sections:

  • Section 16, 17(2), 39(9), 50, 73, 75(4), 107(4), 169(d) of CGST Act, 2017

Facts (Paras 3.1–3.9)

The petitioner, a cotton seed oil manufacturer, availed ITC on taxable supplies. During production, cotton oil cake, an exempt by-product, was generated. Initially, the petitioner did not reverse ITC under Section 17(2), but later, in March 2020, reversed proportionate ITC for FY 2017-18 and 2018-19. Despite this, the department issued a show cause notice under Section 73 in September 2023 alleging wrongful availment of ITC. Without granting a mandatory personal hearing under Section 75(4), an order dated 21.12.2023 confirmed demand of ₹58.08 lakh. The petitioner contended that the ITC reversal was already made before SCN issuance, but the order was passed without considering such facts. Later, recovery actions including bank account attachment were initiated.


Questions before the Court

  1. Whether demand under Section 73 could be sustained when ITC reversal was already effected before issuance of SCN?

  2. Whether denial of hearing under Section 75(4) and uploading of order only on portal vitiated natural justice?

  3. Whether Section 107(4), which bars condonation of delay in filing appeal, is arbitrary?

  4. Whether demand could have been restricted to interest and penalty under Section 50 instead of duplicating tax liability?


Observations (Paras 6–9)

The Court noted that reversal of ITC had been made in March 2020, well before the SCN. The adjudicating authority ignored portal records and wrongly treated ITC as not reversed. Instead of restricting proceedings to levy of interest/penalty for delayed reversal under Section 50, the authority demanded reversal again, causing double taxation. The Court held that while the petitioner did not reply to the SCN, principles of fairness require authorities to verify available records before passing orders. Uploading of orders on the portal constitutes deemed service under Section 169(d), but denial of personal hearing violated Section 75(4).


Judgment (Paras 9–10)

The High Court quashed the Order-in-Original dated 21.12.2023. It held that SCN should have been limited to interest/penalty and not ITC denial. The matter was remanded for de-novo adjudication after providing proper hearing and considering amounts already deposited.


Cases Referred – Tabular Summary

Case Referred Court Verdict/Ratio
No external cases cited in judgment – The judgment relied on interpretation of Sections 16, 39(9), 50, 73, 75 of CGST Act.

Between Fine Lines

For businesses, this judgment clarifies that once ITC is voluntarily reversed before SCN, authorities cannot demand it again. At most, interest and penalty may apply for delayed reversal. It underscores the need for adjudicating authorities to cross-verify GST portal data and respect mandatory hearings under Section 75(4).

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY