Home Case Laws Penalty reduced as non-generation of Part-B of e-way bill for job work...

Penalty reduced as non-generation of Part-B of e-way bill for job work movement was treated as clerical lapse and not tax evasion

0
346

Case Summary

Case Title: M/s Boron Rubbers India v. Union of India & Ors.
Court: High Court of Gujarat, Ahmedabad
Petition No.: R/Special Civil Application No. 9617 of 2023
Judgment Date: 27 March 2025
Category of Dispute: Penalty under Section 129 – E-Way Bill non-compliance (clerical lapse)
Relevant Provisions: Section 68, Section 129(1)(a), Section 143 of CGST Act, 2017; Rule 138 of CGST Rules, 2017; Circular No. 64/38/2018-GST dated 14.09.2018

Facts (Paras 4–5)

The petitioner, engaged in manufacturing of rubber sheets, transported goods under delivery challan for job work from Bhavnagar to Vasai (Maharashtra). An e-way bill (Part A) was generated, but Part-B (vehicle details) was not filled. The goods were detained on 08.08.2018, and penalty of ₹7,36,490/- was imposed under Section 129(1)(a). Though the petitioner contended it was a clerical lapse, he paid under protest and later filed appeal. The appellate authority upheld the penalty, holding violation of Rule 138 CGST Rules.


Questions Before the Court

  • Whether omission to generate Part-B of the e-way bill for job work consignment amounts to intent of tax evasion justifying penalty under Section 129(1)(a)?

  • Whether the authorities erred in not granting hearing before confirming penalty despite petitioner’s reply?

  • Whether Circular 64/2018 mitigates penalty in such clerical lapses?


Observations (Paras 7–10)

The Court noted that:

  • Goods were accompanied by delivery challan and e-way bill Part-A; only Part-B was missing.

  • Passing penalty order prior to scheduled hearing violated principles of natural justice.

  • The petitioner was not a “supplier” but was sending goods for job work under Section 143.

  • Non-generation of Part-B was a technical lapse and could not amount to tax evasion.

  • Circular No. 64/38/2018-GST clarified that in cases of minor documentation errors, proceedings under Section 129 should not be invoked and only nominal penalty under Section 125 may be imposed.


Judgment (Paras 9–11)

The High Court held that penalty under Section 129(1)(a) was disproportionate and without application of mind. It reduced penalty to ₹25,000/- treating the lapse at par with exempted goods. Authorities were directed to refund the balance to the petitioner through electronic cash/credit ledger.


Table of Cases Referred

Case Court & Citation Verdict
Dynamic Rubbers Pvt. Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner (AE) CGST (2024) 24 Centax 293 (Guj.) Gujarat High Court Held that penalty for e-way bill lapses must be proportionate; clerical lapses cannot justify full penalty.

Between Fine Lines

For businesses, this ruling clarifies that minor clerical lapses in e-way bills (such as non-filling of Part-B) while sending goods for job work should not be treated as tax evasion. Authorities cannot mechanically impose 200% penalty under Section 129. Instead, only a nominal penalty is justified. Industries must, however, ensure compliance with e-way bill rules to avoid unnecessary litigation.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY