Home Updates Machinery Returned for Testing Is Not a Supply; E-Way Bill Lapse Attracts...

Machinery Returned for Testing Is Not a Supply; E-Way Bill Lapse Attracts Limited Penalty: Karnataka High Court

0
97

The Karnataka High Court, in State of Karnataka v. AAM India Manufacturing Corporation Private Limited, has upheld a Single Judge’s ruling that the re-transportation of machinery to the original seller for testing, without any fresh consideration, does not constitute a “supply” under Section 7(1)(a) of the CGST and KGST Acts. At the same time, the Court held that the movement was required to be accompanied by an E-way bill and that failure to generate it attracted the applicable statutory penalty.

The judgment was delivered by a Division Bench comprising Justice S.G. Pandit and Justice Rajesh Rai K in Writ Appeal No. 1390 of 2024 on 25 June 2026. The appeal was filed by the State of Karnataka against an order dated 19 January 2023 passed in W.P. No. 16845 of 2022.

Background of the Case

AAM India Manufacturing Corporation Private Limited had purchased hydraulic fixtures and tooling body machines from a supplier situated in Coimbatore. The machinery was initially transported to the company’s unit at Ahmednagar, Maharashtra.

After certain customization work, the machinery was sent back to the seller in Coimbatore for testing. The movement was covered by delivery challans but was not accompanied by E-way bills.

The vehicle carrying the machinery was intercepted by the Commercial Tax Officer on 3 November 2020. A detention order in Form GST MOV-06 and a notice in Form GST MOV-07 were subsequently issued under Section 129(3) of the CGST Act. The company deposited the demanded tax and penalty, following which an ex parte order dated 9 November 2020 confirmed the levy of IGST and penalty.

The appellate authority dismissed the company’s appeal. The company then approached the Karnataka High Court, where the learned Single Judge quashed the appellate order, restricted the penalty to ₹25,000 and directed refund of the remaining amount deposited.

State’s Contentions

The State argued that the company had failed to establish that the return movement of the machinery formed part of the original purchase transaction. According to the State, the movement should therefore be treated as an independent taxable supply.

It was further contended that the machinery was transported without generating the E-way bill required under Rule 138 of the CGST Rules. Since the goods were not exempted goods and the transaction did not fall within any statutory exemption, the authorities were justified in demanding tax and penalty.

Findings of the Division Bench

The Division Bench noted that Section 7(1)(a) of the CGST and KGST Acts treats transactions such as sale, transfer, barter, exchange, licence, rental, lease or disposal as supplies only when they are made or agreed to be made for consideration in the course or furtherance of business.

In the present case, the machinery had already been purchased and transported to the company’s unit. Its subsequent return to the seller was only for testing and did not involve any fresh consideration.

The Court therefore held that the re-transportation did not fall within the scope of “supply” under Section 7(1)(a).

Delivery Challan and E-Way Bill Requirement

The Court referred to Rule 55(1) of the CGST Rules, which permits transportation of goods without issuance of a tax invoice in specified situations, including movement for reasons other than by way of supply. Such movement may be undertaken under a delivery challan.

However, the Court clarified that movement under a delivery challan does not, by itself, dispense with the requirement of generating an E-way bill under Rule 138 where the prescribed conditions are satisfied.

The re-transportation in the present case was not covered by any exemption from E-way bill generation. Consequently, although there was no taxable supply, the company had committed a statutory breach by moving the machinery without an E-way bill.

Limited Penalty Upheld

The Division Bench agreed with the Single Judge that tax could not be demanded merely because the machinery had been transported without an E-way bill, when the underlying movement was not a supply involving consideration.

The Court nevertheless upheld the imposition of the limited penalty applicable under the relevant part of Section 129(1)(a) of the CGST and KGST Acts. It found no error in the Single Judge’s direction restricting the penalty to ₹25,000 and ordering refund of the balance amount deposited by the company.

Accordingly, the State’s writ appeal was dismissed.

Legal Significance

The judgment draws an important distinction between the taxability of a transaction and compliance requirements governing the physical movement of goods.

A movement of goods for testing, repair, job work or another non-supply purpose may not attract GST where there is no consideration and the transaction does not fall within the statutory definition of supply. However, businesses must independently examine whether a delivery challan, E-way bill or other prescribed document is required for such movement.

The absence of a taxable supply does not automatically exempt the movement from procedural requirements under the CGST Rules. At the same time, a procedural lapse in generating an E-way bill cannot by itself convert a non-supply movement into a taxable supply.

Conclusion

The Karnataka High Court has confirmed that machinery returned to the original supplier for testing, without fresh consideration, does not constitute a supply under Section 7(1)(a) of the CGST and KGST Acts.

Nevertheless, where the statutory threshold and conditions under Rule 138 are met, an E-way bill must accompany the goods even when they are transported under a delivery challan for reasons other than supply. Non-compliance may attract the prescribed penalty, but it does not justify levy of GST on a transaction that is otherwise outside the scope of supply.

 

Download

LEAVE A REPLY