The Kerala High Court, in The Secretary, Thrissur Corporation v. E.M. Paulose & Others, has recalled its earlier judgment concerning a contractor’s claim for GST reimbursement in relation to works executed under an agreement with the Kerala Water Authority.
The review petition arose from the judgment dated 7 October 2025 in W.P.(C) No. 35300 of 2025. The review petitioner contended that the earlier judgment proceeded on an incorrect understanding that the dispute concerned payment of the differential GST arising from an increase in the tax rate from 12% to 18%.
Background of the Dispute
The writ petitioner had executed works pursuant to an agreement with the Kerala Water Authority. The earlier proceedings were understood as involving a claim for the differential GST amount following the enhancement of the applicable GST rate.
The Secretary, Thrissur Corporation, who was the fifth respondent in the writ petition, sought review of the judgment. It was argued that the contractual rates quoted by the contractor were expressly inclusive of GST and all other taxes.
According to the review petitioner, since the contract did not separately provide for payment or reimbursement of GST, the contractor’s entitlement to claim GST itself required examination. Consequently, the question was not merely whether the contractor could recover the difference between GST at 12% and GST at 18%.
Issue Before the Kerala High Court
The principal issue in the review petition was whether the earlier judgment contained an apparent error by treating the dispute as one concerning differential GST, even though the contractual price was stated to be inclusive of all taxes.
The Court examined the contractual documents, communications and decisions of the authorities placed before it during the review proceedings.
Kerala High Court’s Findings
Justice Ziyad Rahman A.A. observed that the materials produced before the Court indicated that a claim for differential GST did not independently arise in the circumstances of the case.
The Court accepted that the actual issue requiring consideration was whether the writ petitioner was contractually entitled to claim GST when the accepted tender amount and quoted rates were inclusive of taxes.
The distinction was material. A claim for reimbursement of an increased GST rate presupposes an underlying contractual entitlement to receive GST separately. Where the agreed consideration is inclusive of GST and other taxes, the contractor’s entitlement must first be determined from the terms of the contract and the relevant administrative decisions.
The High Court therefore concluded that the matter required reconsideration.
Judgment Recalled and Writ Petition Restored
The Kerala High Court allowed the review petition and recalled its judgment dated 7 October 2025 in W.P.(C) No. 35300 of 2025.
The writ petition was restored to the Court’s file for fresh consideration of the correct issue, namely, whether the contractor was entitled to claim GST under the contractual arrangement.
The Court did not finally decide the contractor’s substantive entitlement to GST or reimbursement. That question will be examined when the restored writ petition is reconsidered.
Significance of the Decision
The decision highlights the importance of carefully examining the tax clauses contained in government and public works contracts. A contractual rate described as inclusive of GST and other taxes may materially affect a contractor’s right to seek separate reimbursement following a change in the applicable tax rate.
The judgment also demonstrates that a review may be maintainable where the Court’s earlier decision proceeds on an issue that does not accurately reflect the contractual dispute between the parties.
Contractors, government authorities and public sector entities should therefore clearly determine whether the contract provides for a tax-inclusive price, a tax-exclusive price, or reimbursement of statutory variations in taxes. Such clauses may ultimately govern whether any additional GST amount is contractually recoverable.




