Home Updates Madras High Court Sets Aside Demand Notice; Grants Fresh Opportunity to File...

Madras High Court Sets Aside Demand Notice; Grants Fresh Opportunity to File Return

0
219

 

The Madras High Court in Sankaran Mekala v. The Income Tax Officer, WP No. 30966 of 2026 and WMP Nos. 34028 and 34029 of 2026, granted relief to a taxpayer who was unable to upload her Income Tax return due to technical difficulties on the e-filing portal.

The petitioner challenged a demand communication dated 16.07.2026 concerning tax and penalty arising from an earlier assessment order dated 16.01.2024 for Assessment Year 2015-16.

In an earlier writ petition, the Court had directed the petitioner to deposit ₹5 lakh, file the return and submit a reply to the notice issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The petitioner complied with the monetary condition by depositing ₹5 lakh. However, she was unable to upload the return because of technical issues with the Income Tax e-filing portal.

Court’s Findings

The Court noted that the petitioner had produced proof of the ₹5 lakh deposit made in compliance with its earlier direction. She had also placed various supporting documents on record.

A screenshot produced before the Court demonstrated the difficulty faced by the petitioner in uploading the return electronically.

Considering these circumstances, the Court held that the interest of justice required that the petitioner be granted another opportunity to comply with the earlier directions.

Direction of the High Court

The Madras High Court accordingly:

  • set aside the demand communication dated 16.07.2026;
  • directed the Income Tax Department to provide necessary portal access to the petitioner;
  • directed the petitioner to file her return within three weeks; and
  • directed the respondent to complete the assessment within six weeks thereafter, after providing the petitioner a reasonable opportunity of hearing.

Outcome

Demand Notice Set Aside; Matter Remanded for Fresh Assessment.

Key Takeaway

Where a taxpayer substantially complies with the Court’s directions but is prevented from completing electronic filing because of demonstrated technical difficulties on the Income Tax portal, the Court may grant a further opportunity to ensure that the matter is decided after proper compliance and reasonable opportunity.

Case Details

Case: Sankaran Mekala v. The Income Tax Officer
Case No.: WP No. 30966 of 2026 and WMP Nos. 34028 and 34029 of 2026
Court: Madras High Court (Single Judge)
Relevant Provision: Section 148, Income Tax Act, 1961
Outcome: Demand Notice Set Aside; Matter Remanded for Fresh Assessment

Download

LEAVE A REPLY