Home Updates ITO v. Wisdom Inc.: ITAT Rajkot Deletes ₹37 Crore Section 68 Addition...

ITO v. Wisdom Inc.: ITAT Rajkot Deletes ₹37 Crore Section 68 Addition as Loans Were Repaid Through Banking Channels

0
132

 

Case: Income Tax Officer, Ward-2 v. Wisdom Inc.
Citation: ITA No. 699/RJT/2025
Assessment Year: 2023-24
Forum: Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Rajkot Bench, Rajkot
Bench: Dr. Arjun Lal Saini, Accountant Member & Shri Sonjoy Sarma, Judicial Member
Date of Pronouncement: 28 August 2026
Outcome: Revenue’s Appeal Dismissed.

ITAT Rajkot Upholds Deletion of ₹37 Crore Addition under Section 68

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Rajkot Bench, has upheld the deletion of an addition of ₹37 crore made under Section 68 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, where unsecured loans received by the assessee were subsequently repaid through normal banking channels and the loan accounts stood squared up.

Wisdom Inc. had received unsecured loans of ₹21 crore from Bloom Dealers Private Limited and ₹16 crore from Mukund Securities and Investment Limited. During assessment proceedings, the assessee furnished banking evidence and confirmations, while the lenders also responded to notices issued under Section 133(6). However, considering their returned incomes comparatively meagre vis-à-vis the loans advanced, the Assessing Officer held that their creditworthiness had not been established and added ₹37 crore under Section 68.

CIT(A) Deletes the Addition

The CIT(A) deleted the addition after considering documentary evidence regarding repayment of the loans. The appellate authority noted that the loan from Mukund Securities and Investment Limited had been repaid along with interest during the relevant assessment year. A substantial portion of the amount payable to Bloom Dealers Private Limited was also repaid during the year and the balance subsequently repaid.

The CIT(A) relied upon decisions of the Gujarat High Court and held that where repayment of a loan is established through documentary evidence and accepted by the Department, the credit entry cannot be examined in isolation merely for making an addition under Section 68.

ITAT’s Findings

The Tribunal observed that the CIT(A), after examining the documentary evidence, had recorded a categorical finding that the loans had been repaid through normal banking channels and the loan accounts stood squared up. Such repayment through banking channels provided substantial support to the genuineness of the transactions.

The ITAT followed the Gujarat High Court judgment in Principal Commissioner of Income-tax v. Merrygold Gems (P.) Ltd. [2024] 164 taxmann.com 764 (Gujarat), as referred to in the order. It observed that once repayment is duly established through documentary evidence, the loan transaction cannot be viewed in isolation, particularly where the Department has accepted the repayment without drawing any adverse inference.

Accordingly, the Tribunal found no infirmity in the CIT(A)’s deletion of the ₹37 crore addition under Section 68 and dismissed the Revenue’s appeal.

Key Takeaway

Repayment of unsecured loans through established banking channels, supported by documentary evidence and accepted without adverse inference by the Department, is a material circumstance supporting the genuineness of the transactions. On the facts of the case and following the jurisdictional Gujarat High Court precedent, the ITAT upheld deletion of the ₹37 crore Section 68 addition.

Download

LEAVE A REPLY