Home Case Laws Matter to be re-adjudicated in case auditor of firm suffers from cancer

Matter to be re-adjudicated in case auditor of firm suffers from cancer

0
475

Case Title: Kandhasamy Jothimani v. Commercial Tax Officer

Court: High Court of Madras

Petition Number: W.P. No. 8500 of 2024; W.M.P. Nos. 9449 and 9451 of 2024

Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit, Denial due to Belated Filing of Returns

Date of Judgement: 27 March 2024

Relevant Sections: Section 16(4) of CGST Act, 2017

 

Facts of the Case [¶1–2, ¶5]

  • The petitioner, a GST-registered contractor, challenged an assessment order dated 13.09.2023 on the grounds of not being afforded a reasonable opportunity to contest the tax demand [¶1].
  • A show cause notice was issued on 04.05.2023 after scrutiny of the petitioner’s returns. However, the petitioner claims he was unaware of it due to his auditor’s illness (cancer), who failed to inform him of the proceedings [¶2].
  • The petitioner alleged that this situation led to the impugned assessment order being passed ex parte [¶5].

 

Questions in Consideration [¶1, ¶3, ¶6]

  1. Whether the petitioner was denied reasonable opportunity to contest the tax demand under GST proceedings?
  2. Whether the denial of Input Tax Credit under Section 16(4) due to belated filing without personal hearing is sustainable?
  3. Whether the case merits remand upon partial payment by the petitioner?

 

Observation of the Court [¶3–6]

  • The Court acknowledged that a significant portion of the confirmed demand pertained to belated returns and denial of ITC under Section 16(4), where the petitioner claimed to have a valid case on merits [¶3].
  • While the respondent argued that reasonable opportunity was given, the Court noted that the petitioner was not heard before the order was passed, and the circumstances involving the auditor’s illness were relevant [¶4–5].
  • The Court found procedural lapse in not providing a hearing and deemed interference necessary, albeit conditionally [¶5–6].

 

Judgement of the Court [¶6–7]

  • The assessment order dated 13.09.2023 was quashed subject to the condition that the petitioner remits 10% of the disputed tax demand within two weeks [¶6].
  • The petitioner was allowed to submit a reply to the show cause notice within the same period.
  • The respondent was directed to provide a fresh opportunity, including a personal hearing, and to pass a reasoned order within two months of receiving the reply [¶6].
  • The writ petition was accordingly disposed of; no costs were awarded [¶7].

 

Between Fine Lines

  • The Madras High Court quashed the GST assessment order due to violation of natural justice.
  • The petitioner was unaware of proceedings because his auditor was seriously ill.
  • The Court balanced equity and compliance by requiring a 10% pre-deposit.
  • Fresh proceedings with opportunity for hearing were ordered.
  • The judgment reinforces that opportunity of hearing is integral in GST assessments.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name Citation Summary Verdict
None explicitly cited in judgement – – –

 

Takeaway:

“No Tax Without Hearing: Auditor’s Illness No Ground to Deny Natural Justice”

LEAVE A REPLY