Case: M S Steels v. The Commissioner of Kerala State GST, Thiruvananthapuram
Appeal No.: APL/1/TVP/2026
Final Order No.: 01/TVP/KERALA/2026
Forum: Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram Bench (Division Bench)
Date of Order: 14 August 2026
Coram: Hon’ble Shri Subramanya V. Rayaprol, Member (Judicial) and Hon’ble Shri Ramamoorthi Sriram, Member (Technical)
GSTAT Rules on E-Way Bill Penalty in Stock Transfers
The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram Bench, has held that penalty under Section 129 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 and the Kerala Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 is not leviable merely because goods transported as a stock transfer between premises of the same registered person were not accompanied by an e-way bill.
M/s M.S. Steels, a partnership firm dealing in steel goods, transported goods on 13 June 2022 under Delivery Challan No. M120 from its own premises to its own godown under the same GSTIN. The vehicle was intercepted by Mobile Squad No. II, Thiruvananthapuram, and detained for non-availability of an e-way bill. A penalty of ₹1,34,640, comprising CGST of ₹67,320 and SGST of ₹67,320, was imposed under Section 129(3), without any tax demand. The first appellate authority upheld the penalty, following which the assessee approached the GST Appellate Tribunal.
Whether Same-GSTIN Stock Transfer Constitutes “Supply”
The Tribunal examined Sections 7 and 9 of the CGST/KGST Acts and observed that the stock transfer in question involved only one person—the appellant—and there was neither a second party nor any consideration. It therefore held that the movement did not constitute a “supply” within the meaning of Section 7.
Once the movement did not amount to a supply, it could not constitute an intra-State supply attracting the charging provision contained in Section 9. Consequently, no GST was payable on the stock transfer.
Meaning of “Tax Payable” Under Section 129
The Tribunal emphasised that the penalty prescribed under Section 129(1) is linked to the expression “tax payable on such goods.” Where the underlying transaction itself does not attract tax, a penalty computed as a percentage of the tax payable cannot be imposed.
The Tribunal rejected the Revenue’s argument that “tax payable” merely provides a measure for quantifying penalty by reference to the normal GST rate applicable to the goods. Relying on Fabricship Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, it held that the phrase contemplates a transaction on which tax actually becomes payable.
E-Way Bill Requirement Still Applies
Importantly, the Tribunal did not hold that an e-way bill is unnecessary for stock transfers. It recognised that Rule 138(1)(ii) specifically requires an e-way bill for movement of goods exceeding the prescribed value even where such movement is “for reasons other than supply.”
However, the Tribunal held that where such movement does not constitute a taxable supply, penalty under Section 129(3) cannot be invoked merely for non-generation of the e-way bill. According to the Tribunal, the appropriate statutory provision for such document-related contravention is Section 122(1)(xiv) of the CGST/KGST Acts.
Final Decision
The Tribunal answered the question of law in the negative and expressly held that penalty under Section 129 of the CGST/KGST Acts is not leviable on a registered person for transporting goods without an e-way bill when the transportation is undertaken on account of stock transfer.
Accordingly, Order-in-Appeal No. GSTA No. 77/2022 dated 2 November 2022 was set aside and the appeal filed by M/s M.S. Steels was allowed with consequential relief.
Key Takeaway: A same-GSTIN stock transfer between premises of the same registered person does not constitute a “supply” where there are no two distinct persons and no consideration. Therefore, no tax is payable on such movement and the tax-linked penalty under Section 129 cannot be imposed merely because an e-way bill was not generated. The e-way bill requirement under Rule 138(1)(ii), however, continues to apply.




