Home Case Laws Non filing of Part-B of the E-way bill cannot be ground for...

Non filing of Part-B of the E-way bill cannot be ground for seizure where all the requisite documents were presented and no intent to evade tax has been proved.

0
461

Case Title: VSL Alloys (India) Pvt. Ltd. vs. State of U.P.

Court: High Court of Allahabad

Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 637 of 2018

Category: Detention of goods / E-Way Bill Compliance

Date of Judgement: 13 April 2018

Relevant Sections: Section 129(1) and 129(3) of the UPGST Act, 2017; Rule 138(3) of the CGST Rules, 2017

Takeaway: Goods detained for minor procedural lapse despite clear evidence of bona fide transaction

Facts of the Case

  • The petitioner, VSL Alloys (India) Pvt. Ltd., a GST-registered company in Sahibabad, U.P., was transporting stainless steel welded pipes worth ₹5,43,631 to a registered consignee in Rajkot, Gujarat under a valid tax invoice charging 18% IGST …(Para 2).
  • Goods were booked via a transporter and accompanied by an e-way bill (generated on 07.04.2018), but Part-B (vehicle details) was not filled as the goods were first to be transported to the transporter’s warehouse before final shipment …(Paras 3–4).
  • The vehicle was intercepted at 12:15 A.M. on 08.04.2018 by the Mobile Squad, Unit-III, Ghaziabad. A seizure was made under Section 129(1) due to the missing Part-B details on the e-way bill Para 5).
  • The department issued a notice demanding ₹97,854 as tax and an equal amount as penalty under Section 129(3) …(Para 5).

Questions in Consideration

  • Whether omission to fill Part-B of the e-way bill justifies seizure and penalty under Section 129 of the UPGST Act, even when all transactional documents are in order? …(Para 6).
  • Whether the benefit of third proviso to Rule 138(3) of the CGST Rules (exempting vehicle detail for movement within 50 km to transporter) applies in this case? …(Para 10).

Observation of the Court

  • The Court accepted the petitioner’s explanation that Part-B could not be filled due to the nature of movement—i.e., short intra-state movement to the transporter’s warehouse before further interstate dispatch …(Paras 8–10).
  • The relevant Notification No. 12/2018 – Central Tax dated 07.03.2018, which amended Rule 138(3), explicitly provides exemption from furnishing vehicle details in Part-B if goods are transported within 50 km to the transporter’s premises …(Para 10).
  • The Court observed that all required documents including the tax invoice and e-way bill were present and correctly mentioned the transaction details. There was no mala fide intent or attempt to evade tax …(Paras 11–14).
  • The authority failed to consider the explanation and the notification, nor did it provide any reasoning in the seizure order, making the action arbitrary and illegal …(Paras 14–15).

Judgement of the Court

  • The Hon’ble Court quashed the seizure order dated 09.04.2018 and the consequential notice under Section 129(3), holding the detention illegal.
  • It directed immediate release of the goods and vehicle in favour of the petitioner …(Para 15).
  • The writ petition was allowed …(Para 16).

Between Fine Lines

  • If goods are moved within 50 km to a transporter before interstate shipment, Part-B of the e-way bill need not be filled.
  • Seizure merely on account of Part-B omission—when all documents are in place and no intent to evade tax is found—is unjustified.
  • Authorities must apply their mind and examine the notification exemptions before passing detention orders.
  • Bona fide registered dealers should not suffer for procedural lapses in intra-transport movement.
  • Proper reasoning is mandatory in any adverse order under GST law.

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
None referred — The judgement does not cite or refer to any precedent case laws —

 

LEAVE A REPLY