Home Case Laws Opportunity of Cross-Examination is Fundamental under GST Proceedings

Opportunity of Cross-Examination is Fundamental under GST Proceedings

0
396

Case Title: Thangapandi Selvaraj v. Enforcement Officer, Enforcement Squad No. 1
Court: High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam
Petition No.: WP(C) No. 757 of 2025
Judgment Date: 21 January 2025
Category: Principles of Natural Justice / Cross-Examination in GST proceedings
Relevant Section: Section 75(4) of CGST Act, 2017
Citation: 2025:KER:4436


Facts of the Case (Para 1–3)

  • The petitioner, a registered GST dealer engaged in trading aluminium, copper, and brass scrap, faced a search by Enforcement Squad No.1 on 23.05.2024.

  • A Show Cause Notice (SCN) dated 24.09.2024 (Ext.P1) proposed huge tax and penalty relying on statements of two third parties, Mr. Abdul Salam K. and Mr. Shajahan K.T.

  • The petitioner requested cross-examination of the witnesses (Ext.P2, dated 12.11.2024). The request was rejected by the respondent via communication dated 21.11.2024 (Ext.P3), stating that the statements were voluntary and no cross-examination was required.

  • Aggrieved, the petitioner filed this writ petition challenging Ext.P3.


Question(s) in Consideration (Para 2–3, 5–6)

  1. Whether reliance on third-party statements without granting cross-examination violates principles of natural justice?

  2. Does Section 75(4) of the CGST Act mandate an opportunity of cross-examination when statements are used against the taxpayer?


Observations of the Court (Para 5–6)

  • The Court referred to Nishad K.U. v. Joint Commissioner, Central Tax & Excise (2024 SCC Online Ker 7328), holding that rule of law requires granting opportunity to question witnesses when their statements are relied upon.

  • Section 75(4) CGST Act ensures that an opportunity of hearing must be given, and unilateral use of third-party statements behind the back of a person cannot be justified.

  • Since the SCN relied on statements of Abdul Salam and Shajahan, denial of cross-examination contravenes natural justice.


Judgment of the Court (Para 6–7)

  • The Court set aside Ext.P3 dated 21.11.2024.

  • Directed respondent to grant cross-examination of the two witnesses mentioned in the SCN.

  • Proceedings under Ext.P1 SCN to continue only after cross-examination, and to be completed expeditiously in a time-bound manner.

  • Writ petition allowed.


Between Fine Lines (Simplified Outcome in 5 lines)

This case reaffirms that cross-examination is a taxpayer’s right when third-party statements are relied upon. The GST Department cannot deny it on the pretext that statements were voluntary. Section 75(4) CGST ensures a fair hearing, which includes questioning witnesses. The rejection of such a request violates natural justice. Hence, taxpayers can insist on cross-examination in all similar cases.


Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Nishad K.U. v. Joint Commissioner, Central Tax & Excise & Ors. 2024 SCC Online Ker 7328 Court held that opportunity of cross-examination is a fundamental right when statements of third parties are relied upon. Petition allowed; denial of cross-examination struck down.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY