Home Case Laws Separate Adjudication Required Despite Composite SCN

Separate Adjudication Required Despite Composite SCN

0
219

Case Title: M/s. Lakshmi Mobile Accessories v. Joint Commissioner (Intelligence & Enforcement) & Anr.
Court: High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam
Petition No.: WP(C) No. 2911 of 2025
Date of Judgment: 28 January 2025
Category of Dispute: Validity of SCN, Adjudication Procedure
Relevant Sections: Section 74, CGST Act, 2017


Facts of the Case (with Para References)

  1. The petitioner, M/s. Lakshmi Mobile Accessories, challenged SCN dated 29.07.2024 (Ext. P1) issued under Section 74 of CGST Act covering FY 2017-18 to 2023-24. [Para 3]

  2. The SCN proposed imposition of tax, interest, and penalty. A hearing was fixed for 22.08.2024, but petitioner submitted reply belatedly on 03.12.2024. [Para 3]

  3. Petitioner contended that the respondent intended to pass a composite order for all years without granting sufficient opportunity, including denial of cross-examination. [Para 4]

  4. Petitioner sought direction for separate orders for each financial year and adequate opportunity of hearing. [Para 1, 6]


Question(s) in Consideration

  1. Whether issuance of a composite order for multiple years pursuant to a composite SCN under Section 74 is permissible? [Para 6]

  2. Whether the petitioner’s apprehension of denial of cross-examination and opportunity of hearing is justified? [Para 4–5]


Observations of the Court

  1. The Court noted that the petitioner’s apprehensions were assumptions without material, as no contrary procedure was shown to be followed by the authority. [Para 4]

  2. The petitioner was already given opportunity for hearing on 22.08.2024, but chose to file reply only on 03.12.2024. Hence, allegation of insufficient opportunity could not be accepted. [Para 5]

  3. The limitation period for FY 2017-18 expires on 05.02.2025; hence no interference could be made for that year. [Para 5]

  4. For FY 2018-19 onwards, the Court emphasized that separate adjudication orders must be passed notwithstanding a composite SCN, relying upon earlier precedent in WP(C) 35156/2024. [Para 6]


Judgment of the Court

  1. The Court disposed of the writ petition granting liberty to the authority to pass order for FY 2017-18 within limitation, after hearing petitioner. [Para 7]

  2. For subsequent years (2018-19 onwards), the authority was directed to pass separate adjudication orders, granting reasonable opportunity of hearing. [Para 7]


Between Fine Lines (Simple Outcome in 5 Points)

  • A composite SCN can be issued, but separate orders must be passed year-wise.

  • For FY 2017-18, order must be passed before expiry of limitation (05.02.2025).

  • The petitioner’s claim of lack of opportunity was rejected as they themselves delayed filing reply.

  • Cross-examination, if legally required, must be considered at the adjudication stage.

  • Court upheld natural justice by ensuring year-wise adjudication and fair opportunity.


Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Unnamed Single Judge Decision WP(C) No. 35156/2024 Held that even if a composite SCN is issued, separate adjudication orders must be passed year-wise. Court relied on this precedent to direct separate orders for 2018-19 onwards.

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY