Case Summary
Case Title: Kitchen Equipments Manufacturing Co. v. Additional Commissioner Grade 2 (Appeal) and Another
Court: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
Petition No.: Writ Tax No. 1388 of 2023
Date of Judgment: 27.02.2025 (Reserved on 18.02.2025)
Hon’ble Judge: Justice Piyush Agrawal
Category of Dispute: Detention of goods / Penalty under Section 129(3) – E-way bill error
Relevant Sections: Sections 7, 29, 55(1), 129(3) of UPGST Act, 2017; Rule 138 CGST Rules
Facts (Paras 3–5)
The petitioner, a registered manufacturer of kitchen equipment, dispatched goods from Ghaziabad to Pragati Maidan, New Delhi for display at the AAHAR International Exhibition through a delivery challan and proper e-way bill. After conclusion of the exhibition, the goods were sent back to Ghaziabad on 18.03.2023 with an exit slip and fresh challan. The goods were intercepted at Mohan Nagar, Ghaziabad where officers found a discrepancy in the e-way bill — the place of loading was incorrectly mentioned as Ghaziabad instead of New Delhi. Goods were detained and released upon payment of tax and penalty under protest. Appeal filed was dismissed on 14.08.2023, leading to the present writ.
Questions of Law
-
Whether proceedings under Section 129(3) can be sustained for clerical mistakes in e-way bill when genuine documents accompany goods.
-
Whether absence of finding regarding intent to evade tax renders such penalty proceedings unsustainable.
-
Whether non-taxable goods returned after exhibition can be detained on procedural lapses.
Observations (Paras 11–17)
The Court noted that goods were accompanied by genuine documents — delivery challan under Section 55(1), e-way bill, and material entry/exit slips. The only discrepancy was the place of dispatch wrongly shown due to human error. Citing Saurabh Traders (Paras 14, 17–20) and I.C.I. India Ltd., the Court reiterated that procedural defects without mens rea cannot justify penalty. Penalty requires a finding of “intention to evade tax,” which was absent here (Para 13). Further reliance was placed on Shyam Sel & Power Ltd. (2023) and Vacmet India Ltd., both holding that where genuine documents exist and no evasion is intended, proceedings are unjustified.
Judgment (Paras 18–20)
The High Court quashed both impugned orders dated 19.03.2023 and 14.08.2023. It held that proceedings under Section 129 were not justified in absence of intent to evade tax. The writ petition was allowed and any amount deposited by petitioner was directed to be refunded within two months of producing certified copy.
Table of Cases Referred
| Case | Court | Citation | Principle Laid Down |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vacmet India Ltd. v. Addl. Commissioner (Appeal) | Allahabad HC | — | Goods not taxable and accompanied with genuine documents cannot be subjected to Section 129 proceedings. |
| Shyam Sel & Power Ltd. v. State of U.P. | Allahabad HC | (2023) 11 Centax 99 (All) | In absence of finding regarding evasion, penalty under GST not sustainable. |
| Commissioner Commercial Tax U.P. v. S/S Saurabh Traders | Allahabad HC | — | Mens rea essential for penalty; procedural lapses alone insufficient. |
| I.C.I. India Ltd. v. Commissioner of Sales Tax | Allahabad HC | (2003) 134 STC 286 | Procedural defects without intent to evade cannot justify penalty; genuine documents protect taxpayer. |
Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaway)
This judgment reassures businesses that minor clerical errors in e-way bills, when goods are supported by genuine documents and no intent to evade tax exists, cannot be treated as grounds for detention and penalty under Section 129. For trade, it underscores the importance of carrying proper challans and slips, while providing relief against overzealous enforcement for mere procedural lapses.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




