Home Case Laws Reduction of input tax credit in respect of purchase of hides and...

Reduction of input tax credit in respect of purchase of hides and skins to be resold in the course of inter-State trade or commerce was found conflicting with Article 286(3) of the constitution of India.

0
505

Case Title: Hides & Skin Owners Seva Mandal v. State of Gujarat

Court: High Court of Gujarat

Petition No.: R/Special Civil Application No. 19824 of 2019

Category: Input Tax Credit

Date of Judgment: February 6, 2020

Relevant Sections: Article 286(3) of the Constitution of India; Section 15(b) of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956; Section 11(6) of the Gujarat VAT Act, 2003

 

Facts of the Case

  1. The petitioners, a registered association of hides and skins traders, challenged Gujarat Government Notification No. (GHN-14) VAT-2010-S.11(6)(2)-TH dated 29.06.2010. This notification reduced ITC on declared goods like hides and skins when resold in inter-State trade.
  2. The traders paid tax under the Gujarat VAT Act on local purchases of hides and skins and sold these in inter-State commerce, paying CST. They claimed full ITC, assuming it to be reimbursement under Section 15(b) of the CST Act.
  3. The petitioners alleged that this notification contravened Article 286(3) of the Constitution and Section 15(b) of the CST Act, which mandates reimbursement of state tax on declared goods when sold inter-State

 

Questions in Consideration

  1. Whether the impugned notification reducing ITC on declared goods contravenes Article 286(3) of the Constitution and Section 15(b) of the CST Act?
  2. Whether the earlier decision in Kadwani Forge Ltd. v. State of Gujarat concluded this issue, making it res judicata?

 

Observations of the Court

  1. The court noted that the earlier Kadwani Forge Ltd. ruling did not conclusively decide the issue regarding declared goods since it involved manufacturing and sale of different goods. Thus, it passed sub silentio on this question.
  2. Section 15(b) of the CST Act mandates full reimbursement of state tax on declared goods resold inter-State. While states can impose conditions on manner of reimbursement, they cannot reduce the extent of it.
  3. The court clarified that input tax credit under the GVAT Act served as the mechanism for such reimbursement in absence of a specific refund rule, replacing the earlier refund under Rule 45 of Gujarat Sales Tax Rules.

 

Judgment of the Court

  1. The Gujarat High Court read down the impugned notification, holding it inapplicable to declared goods such as hides and skins resold in inter-State trade.
  2. It declared the denial/reduction of ITC in such cases to be violative of Article 286(3) of the Constitution and Section 15(b) of the CST Act.
  3. The court directed the State to allow full ITC to petitioners on such declared goods.

 

Between Fine Lines

  • The Court upheld that tax paid on declared goods like hides and skins must be fully reimbursed if such goods are sold inter-State.
  • The impugned notification’s restriction on ITC was held ultra vires Section 15(b) of the CST Act.
  • States can specify how reimbursement occurs, but not how much.
  • Reimbursement via ITC is permissible, but not with a curtailment in credit amount.
  • Prior judgments lacking discussion on declared goods cannot bind future decisions on that specific point.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict/Use in Judgment
Manickam and Co. v. State of Tamil Nadu [1977] 39 STC 12 (SC) Clarified that reimbursement under Section 15(b) applies to sellers in inter-State sales. Applied – SC interpretation used to support petitioners
State of Gujarat v. Narayan Traders [1979] 43 STC 516 (Guj.) Refund permissible if CST paid and declared goods sold inter-State. Relied on to affirm legislative intent.
Modi Spinning & Weaving Mills Co. Ltd. [1965] 16 STC 310 (SC) Declared goods taxability modified by Section 15(a) CST Act. Referred for interpretative support.
Municipal Corp. of Delhi v. Gurnam Kaur AIR 1989 SC 38 Sub silentio doctrine explained – issues not deliberated upon are not binding precedent. Used to refute State’s reliance on Kadwani Forge.
State of U.P. v. Synthetics & Chemicals Ltd. [1991] 4 SCC 139 Unconsidered issues are not binding precedents. Cited for sub silentio doctrine.
Arnit Das v. State of Bihar [2000] 5 SCC 488 Similar ruling on sub silentio principle. Reinforced prior citation.
Premium Granites v. State of Tamil Nadu [1994] 2 SCC 691 Discretionary relaxations allowed under MMRD Act. Held not applicable to current facts.
Vrajlal Manilal v. State of M.P. 1986 Supp SCC 201 Upheld differential tax on tendu leaves. Found unrelated to the present case.
East India Tobacco Co. v. State of A.P. AIR 1962 SC 1733 State can tax select goods unless law operates unequally. Found inapplicable as no Art. 14 challenge raised.
State of U.P. v. Kamla Palace [2000] 1 SCC 557 Greater legislative leeway in economic laws. Distinguished from this case

 

Download Judgement

LEAVE A REPLY