Case Summary
Refund of GST Paid Twice Allowed as Detention Demand Under GST MOV-10 Cannot Be Recovered Twice
Case Title: Nitin v. Union of India & Ors
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 2952/2023 & CM Appl. 42595/2023
Category: Refund – Double Payment of Tax/Penalty/Fine – Detention under Section 129
Date of Judgment: 20 November 2023
Relevant Provisions:
-
CGST Act: Sections 54 (Refund), 129 (Detention, Seizure and Release of Goods and Conveyances)
-
CGST Rules: Rule 97A (Manual filing permitted where electronic functionality not available)
Source: Delhi High Court judgment reproduced from uploaded file
Facts of the Case (Paras 1–2.6)
The petitioner, a transporter, was engaged to carry dried arecanuts purchased by M/s Sharma Enterprises, Delhi from Rohit Company, Karnataka in truck No. KA-14-C-2751. During transit, the vehicle was intercepted on 26.02.2022 at Songadh, Gujarat for non-availability of a valid E-Way Bill; although the invoice dated 21.02.2022 was produced, the statutory e-way bill could not be furnished. Summons were issued on 27.02.2022, and the proper officer quantified tax, penalty and fine totalling ₹40,85,375 under GST MOV-10 dated 28.02.2022.
As the truck was detained, the petitioner deposited the entire quantified amount on 01.03.2022 after obtaining temporary GST registration. Subsequently, on 04.03.2022, the supplier (Rohit Sharma) independently deposited the same quantified amount for release of the goods. Upon verification that dues were satisfied, the authorities released both the goods and the vehicle. Thus, the same demand stood discharged twice—once by the transporter and once by the supplier. The petitioner later sought refund but could not file an application online due to absence of an enabling option on the GST portal.
Questions/Issues (Derived from Paras 1, 3, 6)
-
Whether the GST authorities can retain amounts collected twice (once from the transporter and again from the supplier) under GST MOV-10 proceedings.
-
Whether refund can be denied merely because the online GST portal does not provide an electronic facility to file refund applications for such payments.
-
Whether the transporter, who is not the supplier of goods, is entitled to refund of the excess amount paid under Section 129 proceedings.
Court’s Observations (Paras 3–8)
The Court noted that the quantified amount under GST MOV-10 had undisputedly been paid twice, once by the petitioner and once by the supplier. Since the petitioner was merely a transporter and not the taxable person responsible for discharging tax liability on supply, the Court held that the petitioner had borne the burden only due to detention of his vehicle. The Court emphasised that dual collection of tax, penalty and fine is impermissible in law and violates the statutory scheme of Section 129.
The Court further observed that the petitioner’s grievance stems solely from the absence of a portal mechanism enabling refund applications for this category of payments. As such, the legitimate claim for refund cannot be frustrated due to technical limitations of the GSTN portal. The respondents also conceded that, in absence of online functionality, a manual refund application is an accepted mode under the legal framework, consistent with Rule 97A.
Judgment / Verdict (Paras 9–11)
The High Court disposed of the writ petition by:
-
Permitting the petitioner to file a manual refund application before the jurisdictional officer (Respondent No. 3).
-
Directing the concerned officer to process the refund expeditiously, preferably within four weeks of submission of the manual application.
-
Recognising that the second payment cannot be retained, the Court affirmed that refund is mandatorily due to the petitioner.
Case Law Table (Summary of Referred Cases)
The judgment does not refer to any external case law. Hence, the table notes this fact.
| Sr. No. | Case Referred | Court | Issue | Verdict | Relevance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | No external precedents referred | — | — | — | The decision is based wholly on statutory interpretation and undisputed facts. |
Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaways for Trade/Industry)
This order underscores that dual recovery under detention proceedings is impermissible and that transporters compelled to pay tax/penalty for release of detained goods retain a clear statutory right to refund where the liability is discharged again by the supplier. Further, the GST portal’s limitations cannot prejudice substantive refund rights; manual applications remain valid where electronic modules are unavailable. Businesses should meticulously verify whether any payment made during detention proceedings has subsequently been duplicated by suppliers to avoid unjust enrichment of the exchequer.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




