Case Summary
W.P.(C) 14945/2023, 2039/2024, 4834/2024, 4979/2024, 9801/2024
High Court of Delhi
Show Cause Notices on Secondment – Valuation under Rule 28 – Applicability of CBIC Circular No. 210/4/2024-GST
Judgment dated 22.10.2024
Facts of the Case (Paras 1–8)
The petitioners—Metal One Corporation India Pvt. Ltd., Idemitsu Lube India Pvt. Ltd., Sony India Pvt. Ltd., Petronas Energy India Pvt. Ltd., and Mitsui & Co. India Pvt. Ltd.—received SCNs alleging GST liability under Section 73 of the CGST Act, 2017, read with Section 20 of the IGST Act, for alleged “import of services” arising from secondment of foreign expatriate employees by their overseas group entities. The SCNs alleged that reimbursements of salary constituted consideration for manpower supply under Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. (2022) 17 SCC 90.
The petitioners argued that their expatriates were employees under employment agreements with the Indian entities and that valuation, even if service existed, must follow Rule 28, especially the second proviso. During proceedings, petitioners highlighted CBIC Circular No. 210/4/2024-GST (Para 3.7) clarifying that where full input tax credit is available and no invoice is raised for services from a foreign affiliate, the value of supply must be deemed “Nil.”
Respondents argued that expatriates remained employees of foreign entities and that reimbursements were taxable supplies between related parties. They asserted that valuation must include the entire salary cost in foreign and Indian currencies (Paras 13–14).
Questions Before the Court (Paras 9–12)
-
Whether the secondment of foreign employees constitutes a ‘supply’ and an ‘import of service’ under the CGST/IGST Act?
-
If such supply exists, what is the correct valuation mechanism under Rule 28 of the CGST Rules, 2017?
-
Whether Para 3.7 of CBIC Circular No. 210/4/2024-GST mandating ‘Nil’ valuation, where no invoice is raised and full ITC is available, binds the Department and extinguishes tax liability?
-
Whether continuation of SCNs and OIOs is permissible once value becomes ‘Nil’?
Court’s Observations (Paras 9–14)
The Court restricted itself to valuation under Rule 28, as the petitioners had chosen not to contest the substantive issue of secondment. It reproduced Rule 28 and emphasized the Second Proviso, which deems the invoice value as open market value where full ITC is available.
Critically, the Court examined Circular No. 210/4/2024-GST (Para 3.7), which states that if:
-
full ITC is available and
-
no invoice is raised by the domestic entity for services provided by the foreign affiliate,
the value must be deemed ‘Nil’.
Since the petitioners had not raised invoices, the Court held that the value must necessarily be deemed “Nil.” Once valuation is Nil, no tax, interest, or penalty can arise.
The Court acknowledged possible conceptual problems with CBIC’s position but held it binding on the tax authorities (Para 13). It also held that continuation of proceedings would be futile, as no taxable value existed (Paras 14).
Judgment (Paras 15–19)
-
SCNs quashed for all petitioners:
-
29.09.2023 (W.P.(C) 14945/2023)
-
28.09.2023 (W.P.(C) 2039/2024)
-
27.09.2023 (W.P.(C) 4834/2024)
-
28.09.2023 (W.P.(C) 4979/2024)
-
31.05.2024 (W.P.(C) 9801/2024)
-
-
Orders-in-Original dated 29.12.2023 and 30.12.2023 quashed, including interest and penalty imposed on Sony India Pvt. Ltd., as even its voluntary payment was rendered unnecessary after issuance of the CBIC circular.
-
Clarification: The judgment is confined strictly to the secondment valuation issue; all other issues raised in SCNs remain open for adjudication.
Summary of Cases Referred
| Case Name | Court / Citation | Issue | Verdict Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| CCE & Service Tax v. Northern Operating Systems Pvt. Ltd. (2022) 17 SCC 90 | Supreme Court of India | Whether secondment arrangements constitute manpower supply liable to service tax. | Held that secondment from overseas entities with salary reimbursements amounts to manpower supply; triggered initiation of GST SCNs in present case. |
| Circular No. 210/4/2024-GST (CBIC) | Administrative Circular | Valuation of services between related parties under Rule 28. | Clarifies that if full ITC is available and no invoice is raised, the value of supply must be deemed “Nil”. Bound the Department, resulting in quashing of SCNs. |
Between the Fine Lines (Practical Takeaways for Trade/Industry)
This judgment materially alters the GST position on secondment. Even assuming secondment is a taxable import of service, valuation collapses to ‘Nil’ in all cases where:
-
the Indian entity and foreign affiliate are related parties,
-
full ITC is available, and
-
no invoice is raised by the domestic entity.
This effectively eliminates GST exposure, interest, and penalties for secondment structures that meet these parameters. Businesses should review secondment arrangements and ensure compliance with Rule 28 to avoid unnecessary tax disputes.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




