Home Case Laws Refund of ITC allowed as advisory support services to foreign parent were...

Refund of ITC allowed as advisory support services to foreign parent were held to be export of services, not intermediary services, and place of supply remained outside India under Section 13(2) IGST Act.

0
380

CASE SUMMARY

M/s Cube Highways and Transportation Assets Advisor Pvt. Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner, CGST Division & Ors.
Delhi High Court
W.P.(C) 14427/2022, W.P.(C) 14461/2022 & W.P.(C) 6014/2023
Category: Refund of ITC – Export of Services – Intermediary vs. Advisory Services – Place of Supply
Date of Judgment: 17 August 2023
Relevant Provisions: Section 2(6), 2(13), 13(2), 13(3)(b), 13(4), 13(8)(b) of IGST Act; Section 54 CGST Act
Source: Delhi High Court Judgment (uploaded)


FACTS (Paras 1–23)

The petitioner, Cube Highways and Transportation Assets Advisor Pvt. Ltd., rendered investment advisory and analytical support services to I Squared Asia Advisors Pte. Ltd., Singapore, under an Amended Support Service Agreement dated 06.06.2015. The services included market intelligence, identification of investment opportunities, due diligence support, management consulting and operational advisory.

Before GST, the same services were accepted as export of services, and refund of accumulated CENVAT credit was granted (para 45–47). For FYs 2018–19, 2019–20, and 2020–21, the petitioner filed refund applications of unutilised ITC under Section 54 CGST Act, claiming that services were exported as the recipient was located outside India and consideration was received in foreign exchange.

However, the Adjudicating Authority rejected the refunds, alleging that:

  1. The petitioner acted as an intermediary under Section 2(13) IGST Act (paras 6–11).

  2. The place of supply was in India under Sections 13(3)(b) and 13(4) IGST Act because services allegedly related to immovable property (roads, tolls) and required presence of recipient (paras 15–23).

  3. Invoices mentioned the place of supply as Delhi.

The Appellate Authority affirmed the rejection, holding that petitioner acted as liaison/communication channel between foreign principal and Indian stakeholders, amounting to intermediary services (paras 12, 21–23).


QUESTIONS FOR DETERMINATION (Paras 24–29, 47–53)

  1. Whether the petitioner’s advisory services constituted “intermediary services” under Section 2(13) IGST Act.

  2. Whether the place of supply could be determined under Sections 13(3)(b) (personal services) or 13(4) (immovable property) instead of the general rule under Section 13(2).

  3. Whether rejection orders travelled beyond the scope of show cause notices.

  4. Whether the services constituted “export of services” under Section 2(6) IGST Act, thus entitling refund of ITC.


COURT’S OBSERVATIONS (Paras 32–54)

1. Petitioner provided advisory services on a principal-to-principal basis (Paras 33–35).

The Agreement expressly stated that the petitioner is not an agent, cannot negotiate or conclude deals, and only provides advisory and analytical support. The Court noted that all services were advisory and there was no evidence of facilitation of third-party supplies.

2. Essential elements of “intermediary” absent (Paras 36–44).

The Court relied on CBIC Circular dated 20.09.2021 and Service Tax jurisprudence to reiterate that:

  • Intermediary requires three parties and two distinct supplies (para 42–43).

  • A person providing the main service on his own account cannot be an intermediary (para 41).

  • Petitioner directly rendered advisory services to I Squared; it did not arrange supply between two others.

Thus, the finding of “intermediary services” was held fundamentally flawed (paras 37–39).

3. Section 13(3)(b) IGST Act inapplicable – no personal services (Paras 52).

This clause applies only to personal services requiring the physical presence of the recipient (e.g., beauty treatment). Here, services were rendered through reports and analyses sent overseas, without physical presence.

4. Section 13(4) IGST Act inapplicable – not services directly in relation to immovable property (Paras 53).

The Court found that advisory services concerning investment decisions are not directly in relation to immovable property; they are not architectural, real estate or construction coordination services.

5. Section 13(2) applies – place of supply is the location of recipient, i.e., Singapore.

As none of the exceptions applied, the general rule applied, making the place of supply outside India, satisfying Section 2(6)(iii) IGST Act.

6. Authorities travelled beyond SCN (Paras 48–49).

New allegations under Sections 13(3)(b) and 13(4) IGST Act were never mentioned in the SCNs. Thus, such reasoning was unsustainable.


JUDGMENT / VERDICT (Paras 55–58)

The Delhi High Court held:

  • The petitioner is not an intermediary.

  • The services do not fall under Section 13(3)(b) or 13(4) IGST Act.

  • The place of supply is outside India under Section 13(2).

  • All five conditions of export of services under Section 2(6) IGST Act are satisfied.

  • Refund rejection orders for all three years are set aside.

  • Authorities directed to process refund claims within eight weeks.


SUMMARY OF CASES REFERRED – TABULAR FORM

Case Citation / Reference Court’s Holding Relevance
Ernst & Young Ltd. v. Addl. Commissioner, CGST Appeals-II 2023:DHC:2116-DB Advisory services to foreign entities are not intermediary services. Applied to hold Cube Highways is not an intermediary.
Ohmi Industries Asia Pvt. Ltd. v. Assistant Commissioner, CGST 2023:DHC:2440-DB Same principle: advisory services are exports. Reinforced Court’s reasoning.
BSNL v. Union of India 2023:DHC:2482-DB Remand appropriate only when limitation alone decided or nature of services unclear. Distinguished; remand refused in present case.
GAP International Sourcing (India) Pvt. Ltd. W.P.(C) 11399/2022 Remand when nature of services unclear. Distinguished; nature of services here was clear.

BETWEEN FINE LINES – PRACTICAL TAKEAWAYS

Businesses providing market research, advisory, analytical support or back-office consulting to overseas affiliates can safely claim that such services are export of services, provided they operate on a principal-to-principal basis and do not facilitate third-party transactions. Authorities cannot label such services as “intermediary” merely because the advice relates to Indian entities or assets. Place of supply remains outside India, making refund of ITC admissible.


CLASSIFICATION OF THE CASE UNDER GST LAW

Primary Classification: Refund of ITC on Export of Services
Sub-classification: Intermediary vs. Advisory Services – Place of Supply under Section 13 – Eligibility of Export Status

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY