Home Case Laws Seizure of silver bars and cash quashed as the Court held that...

Seizure of silver bars and cash quashed as the Court held that Section 67 GST search powers do not extend to seizing valuable assets lacking evidentiary relevance or confiscability, and failure to issue notice under Section 67(3)/(7) mandated their immediate release.

0
283

Case Summary: Deepak Khandelwal v. Commissioner of CGST (Delhi High Court)


Case Identification

  • Case Title: Deepak Khandelwal Proprietor, M/s Shri Shyam Metal v. Commissioner of CGST, Delhi West & Anr.

  • Court: High Court of Delhi at New Delhi

  • Petition No.: W.P.(C) 6739/2021

  • Date of Judgment: 17 August 2023

  • Bench: Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav

  • Relevant Provisions:

    • Section 67(1), 67(2), 67(3), 67(6), 67(7), 67(11) – CGST Act

    • Definition Sections 2(52), 2(75), 2(101) – CGST Act

    • Section 130 – Confiscation under CGST Act

  • Category of Dispute: Search & Seizure | Section 67 | Release of Seized Goods


Facts of the Case (Paras 1–7)

The petitioner, a registered dealer trading in non-ferrous metals, was subjected to a search at his residence on 28.01.2020 under Section 67(2). During the search, officers seized:

  • Silver bars weighing 29.5 kg and 14.5 kg

  • ₹7,00,000 Indian currency

  • Multiple mobile phones, cheque books, sale bill book, kachha parchis

(Refer to detailed seizure list at Page 2–3 of uploaded file: )

The petitioner was arrested the next day (29.01.2020) under Section 132(1)(i) CGST Act and later released on bail.

Subsequently, a Section 74 notice dated 10.11.2020 was issued by the Delhi State GST authority proposing a demand of ₹24.20 lakh. The petitioner argued that none of the seized items were relied upon in the SCN, thereby rendering the seizure purposeless.

He later sought release of seized silver and cash, contending that no confiscation notice under Section 67(7) was issued within six months.


Questions / Issues Before the Court (Paras 8–13)

  1. Can officers seize cash and silver bars under Section 67(2) CGST Act when such items are not “goods liable for confiscation” nor “documents/books/things” relevant to proceedings?

  2. Does Section 67 permit seizure of items simply because they appear unaccounted?

  3. Are seized goods required to be returned if:

    • no notice under Section 67(7) is issued within six months; or

    • the items are not relied upon in a subsequent notice as per Section 67(3)?

  4. Does the word “things” in Section 67(2) include cash or valuable assets?


Observations of the Court (Paras 14–62)

A. Scheme & Limits of Section 67 (Paras 14–26)

The Court emphasised:

  • Section 67 is not a tax recovery provision.

  • Seizure is permissible only when goods are liable for confiscation or documents/books/things contain evidentiary material useful for proceedings.

  • Section 67 must be strictly construed due to its invasive nature.

B. Whether silver bars are “goods”? (Para 30)

Silver bars are movable property and are not securities. Therefore, they fall under Section 2(52) – goods, but can be seized only if they are “goods liable to confiscation”, which the Department failed to establish.

C. Whether cash is “goods” or “things”? (Paras 31–32)

  • Cash is money, specifically excluded from definition of goods.

  • It cannot be seized as goods liable for confiscation.

  • Nor is it a “thing” because “things” must be read ejusdem generis with “documents” and “books”—that is, items containing information, not value.

D. Meaning of “things” under Section 67 (Paras 38–47)

“Things” includes:

  • hard drives

  • mobile phones

  • documents containing information

Not included:

  • valuable assets (cash, bullion)

  • items with no evidentiary linkage

The Court noted seizure powers must not become a tool for securing unaccounted wealth, which is the domain of Income Tax Act, not GST.

E. No evidentiary value shown (Paras 55–56)

The Department admitted:

  • Silver bars and cash were seized only because they appeared unaccounted.

  • No material existed correlating these items with any specific fake invoices or GST evasion scheme.

F. Invocation of Section 67(3): Items not relied upon must be returned (Paras 60–62)

The SCN issued under Section 74 did not rely on seized items. Therefore:

  • Section 67(3) mandated their return within 30 days.

  • Section 67(7) also required return if no confiscation notice issued within six months.

Both conditions triggered mandatory release.


Judgment / Verdict (Para 63)

The High Court held:

  1. Seizure of silver bars and cash was illegal because these items were not:

    • goods liable for confiscation; or

    • things containing evidentiary material relevant to GST proceedings.

  2. Failure to issue notice under Section 67(7) within six months required return of seized goods.

  3. Failure to rely on seized items in subsequent SCN triggered Section 67(3) requiring their return within 30 days.

  4. The Court directed immediate release of:

    • silver bars

    • ₹7 lakh Indian currency

    • all other seized articles
      (Ref: Para 63 – uploaded file )

  5. Revenue may continue other lawful proceedings, but cannot retain the seized items.


Cases Referred – Summary Table

Case Name Court Principle / Verdict
I.J. Rao v. Bibhuti Bhushan Bagh (1989) 3 SCC 202 Supreme Court Delay beyond six months in issuing confiscation notice mandates release of seized goods unless period extended lawfully.
Kanishka Matta v. UOI (2020) MP High Court Held cash could be seized as “things”; Delhi HC expressly declined to follow this view.
Emperor v. Hasan Mama (AIR 1940 Bom 378) Bombay HC “Thing” must be read ejusdem generis with preceding words. Valuable movable property not included.
RBI v. Peerless (1987) 1 SCC 424 Supreme Court Statutory interpretation must respect context and purpose, not merely literal meaning.
Balram Kumawat (2003) SC Supreme Court Contextual interpretation required; statutes read as a whole.
State of West Bengal v. UOI (1963) SC Supreme Court Provisions interpreted with reference to entire statute to preserve coherence.

Between Fine Lines (Trade/Industry Takeaways)

This judgment critically restricts the GST Department’s powers under Section 67. Businesses can safely assert that officers cannot seize cash, bullion, or valuables during GST search unless such items possess direct evidentiary value relevant to GST evasion, not merely because they appear unaccounted. If seized, they must be returned if no confiscation notice is issued within six months or if not relied upon in SCN. This ruling provides strong protection against misuse of search powers by distinguishing GST enforcement from income-tax-style seizure of assets.


Classification Under GST Act 2017

Chapter: Inspection, Search & Seizure
Provision: Section 67 – Search & Seizure
Nature: Legality of seizure of non-taxable assets / compliance with statutory time limits

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY