Case Title: M/s Nokia Solutions and Networks India Pvt. Ltd.
Court: High Court of Karnataka
Petition No.: WP No. 14827 of 2022 (T-RES)
Category of Dispute: Refund, Export of Services, Intermediary Services
Date of Judgment: 22nd August 2024
Relevant Sections:
-
Section 2(6), 2(13), 16(1)(a) of the IGST Act
-
Sections 54(1), 54(4) of the CGST Act
-
Rule 89(2)(c) of the CGST Rules
Between Fine Lines (Plain English Summary in 5 lines):
The High Court ruled in favour of Nokia, stating that their export services were rendered on a principal-to-principal basis and did not qualify as “intermediary services.” The refund rejection based on missing FIRCs and classification was found unjustified. The Court emphasized that procedural lapses alone can’t deny substantive rights. Multiple High Court precedents were cited favouring Nokia. The impugned SCNs and appellate orders were quashed as being contrary to law.
Facts of the Case (Paras 2–7):
-
The petitioner, M/s Nokia Solutions and Networks India Pvt. Ltd., engaged in providing software and IT support services to overseas group entities, filed refund claims for unutilized ITC from April 2018 to March 2020.
-
Refunds were partly sanctioned by the Assistant Commissioner (Respondent No. 3) via orders dated 24.04.2020, 28.05.2020, 29.07.2020, and 03.10.2020.
-
The revenue appealed, citing non-submission of FIRCs/BRCs, discrepancy in bank details, and alleging the services were “intermediary services.”
-
During appeal, a Show Cause Notice (SCN) was issued on 06.09.2021 (Annexure-B), followed by another SCN on 07.07.2022 (Annexure-C).
-
An ex-parte recovery order dated 26.07.2022 was also issued, prompting Nokia to file the writ petition.
Questions in Consideration (Para 1 & 12):
-
Whether non-filing of FIRCs/BRCs can be sole ground for refund rejection under Rule 89(2)(c)?
-
Whether the services provided by the petitioner are “intermediary services” under Section 2(13) of the IGST Act?
-
Whether procedural discrepancies in remittance details justify overturning refund sanctions already granted?
Observations of the Court (Paras 13–14):
-
On FIRCs/BRCs: RBI had discontinued FIRCs, and Nokia submitted FIRAs and eBRCs later. Non-submission at initial stage is not fatal when evidence is later provided (Para 13(i)).
-
On bank discrepancies: The difference in bank account numbers and remittance location was held as immaterial since both accounts belonged to Nokia (Para 13(iii)).
-
On classification as Intermediary Services: The Court referred to CBIC Circular No. 159/15/2021-GST and various judgments, holding that services rendered on own account cannot be intermediaries (Para 13(xiii), 13(xiv)).
-
The contract and APA revealed Nokia was developing and delivering software independently, establishing principal-to-principal supply (Para 13(xii), 13(xiii)).
-
Reliance was placed on multiple precedents including Genpact, Ernst & Young, and Ohmi Industries which supported the petitioner’s position (Paras 13(xiv)–13(xvi)).
Judgment of the Court (Para 15):
-
Writ Petition was allowed.
-
The impugned appellate order dated 18.05.2022, SCNs dated 06.09.2021 and 07.07.2022, and recovery order dated 26.07.2022 were quashed.
-
The Court held the rejection of refund and classification of the petitioner as intermediary were illegal, arbitrary, and without jurisdiction.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| ABB India Ltd. v. UOI | 2020 (373) ELT 205 (Kar) | Technical lapses like missing documents can’t deny export benefits if export is proven. | Relief granted |
| Handicrafts & Handlooms v. UOI | 2018 (359) ELT 170 (Mad) | Delay in BRC submission shouldn’t lead to refund denial on technical grounds. | Refund denial quashed |
| Jindal Drugs Ltd. v. Commr. Customs | 2018 (360) ELT 988 (Bom) | Refund can’t be rejected for lack of documents if other evidence is present. | Refund allowed |
| Zandu Chemicals v. UOI | 2014 SCC OnLine Bom 5002 | Procedural lapses shouldn’t outweigh proof of actual exports. | Rebate restored |
| Genpact India Pvt. Ltd. v. UOI | 2022 SCC OnLine P&H 425 | Software services provided on own account are not intermediary services. | Refund upheld |
| Ernst & Young Ltd. v. CGST | 2023 SCC OnLine Del 1764 | Services provided by professional firm are not intermediary. | Refund allowed |
| Ohmi Industries Asia v. CGST | 2023 SCC OnLine Del 2029 | Only services facilitating between two others are intermediary. | Petitioner not intermediary |
| Xilinx India v. Commr. | 2023 SCC OnLine Del 5628 | Indian subsidiary providing services to foreign parent is not intermediary. | Refund ordered to be processed |
| Boks Business Services v. CGST | 2023 SCC OnLine Del 5312 | Back-office services provided directly are not intermediary in nature. | Refund rejection quashed |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




