Home Case Laws Penalty and Interest Quashed on ITC Deposited Under Protest Without Tax Demand...

Penalty and Interest Quashed on ITC Deposited Under Protest Without Tax Demand Determination

0
373

Case Details

  • Case Title: Shyama Power India Ltd. vs. State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors.

  • Court: High Court of Himachal Pradesh, Shimla

  • Petition Number: CWP No. 6990 of 2025

  • Date of Judgment: 19.06.2025

  • Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Tarlok Singh Chauhan and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sushil Kukreja

  • Relevant Section: Section 74 and Section 161 of HP GST Act, 2017; Rule 101(4) of HP GST Rules, 2017

  • Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC), Interest and Penalty, Procedural Fairness


Facts of the Case (¶3–¶13)

  • The petitioner, Shyama Power India Ltd., provides construction services for hydro-electric transmission lines (SAC 9954, 9987) and is registered under HP GST.

  • An audit under Section 65 was initiated, suspecting ITC wrongly availed (Rs. 1.11 crores) based on transactions with three suppliers.

  • Despite providing detailed responses with supporting documents, the department issued an audit memo and later, a final audit report without identifying tax liability.

  • Under pressure, the petitioner reversed ITC of Rs. 1,11,45,134/- on 31.03.2023 under protest using DRC-03.

  • On 02.12.2023, respondent No. 4 (Commissioner) passed an order under Section 74 imposing Rs. 1,32,34,923/- as interest and Rs. 1,11,45,134/- as penalty — treating the ITC reversal as an admission of liability.

  • Appeal was not permitted on the tax amount since the portal showed nil basic demand; rectification was sought under Section 161, which was rejected.


Question(s) in Consideration (¶1, ¶13, ¶15)

  1. Whether ITC reversed under protest can be treated as admitted tax liability for the purpose of levying interest and penalty under Section 74?

  2. Whether the denial of rectification under Section 161 was valid when appeal could not be filed due to technical constraints?


Observations of the Court

  • Deposit Under Protest Not Admission of Liability (¶16–¶17): The court emphasized that any payment made under protest retains the taxpayer’s right to dispute it. Treating it as a voluntary payment or admitted liability was legally untenable.

  • No Independent Inquiry by Authority (¶18): The authority failed to conduct any independent investigation or collect corroborative evidence regarding the alleged ITC fraud.

  • Violation of Natural Justice (¶19): Relying solely on payment under protest without adjudicating the underlying tax demand is a gross procedural irregularity.

  • Portal Constraint Acknowledged (¶12): The inability to file appeal due to portal design, which showed nil demand, cannot deprive the petitioner of appellate remedy.


Judgment of the Court (¶20–¶21)

  • The impugned order dated 02.12.2023 passed under Section 74, levying interest and penalty, was quashed.

  • Respondent No. 4 was directed to issue a fresh DRC-07 indicating only the disputed tax amount (Rs. 1,11,45,134/-) to facilitate appeal on merits.

  • Liberty was granted to the petitioner to raise all legal and factual grounds in the appeal.


🧾 Between Fine Lines

  1. Reversal of ITC under protest is not an admission of tax liability.

  2. Authorities cannot levy interest and penalty without determining tax due through proper inquiry.

  3. Procedural lapses such as denying appellate remedy via portal were found violative of natural justice.

  4. Taxpayers have the right to contest ITC reversal even after making payment under protest.

  5. The court reaffirmed the principle that form cannot override substance in GST proceedings.


📚 Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict/Usage
No specific case law cited – Court relied on principles of procedural fairness and interpretation of “under protest” from Black’s Law Dictionary Used definition of “under protest” to reinforce taxpayer’s right to appeal post-payment

 

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY