Case Details
-
Case Title: Shyama Power India Ltd. vs. State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors.
-
Court: High Court of Himachal Pradesh, Shimla
-
Petition Number: CWP No. 6990 of 2025
-
Date of Judgment: 19.06.2025
-
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Tarlok Singh Chauhan and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sushil Kukreja
-
Relevant Section: Section 74 and Section 161 of HP GST Act, 2017; Rule 101(4) of HP GST Rules, 2017
-
Category of Dispute: Input Tax Credit (ITC), Interest and Penalty, Procedural Fairness
Facts of the Case (¶3–¶13)
-
The petitioner, Shyama Power India Ltd., provides construction services for hydro-electric transmission lines (SAC 9954, 9987) and is registered under HP GST.
-
An audit under Section 65 was initiated, suspecting ITC wrongly availed (Rs. 1.11 crores) based on transactions with three suppliers.
-
Despite providing detailed responses with supporting documents, the department issued an audit memo and later, a final audit report without identifying tax liability.
-
Under pressure, the petitioner reversed ITC of Rs. 1,11,45,134/- on 31.03.2023 under protest using DRC-03.
-
On 02.12.2023, respondent No. 4 (Commissioner) passed an order under Section 74 imposing Rs. 1,32,34,923/- as interest and Rs. 1,11,45,134/- as penalty — treating the ITC reversal as an admission of liability.
-
Appeal was not permitted on the tax amount since the portal showed nil basic demand; rectification was sought under Section 161, which was rejected.
Question(s) in Consideration (¶1, ¶13, ¶15)
-
Whether ITC reversed under protest can be treated as admitted tax liability for the purpose of levying interest and penalty under Section 74?
-
Whether the denial of rectification under Section 161 was valid when appeal could not be filed due to technical constraints?
Observations of the Court
-
Deposit Under Protest Not Admission of Liability (¶16–¶17): The court emphasized that any payment made under protest retains the taxpayer’s right to dispute it. Treating it as a voluntary payment or admitted liability was legally untenable.
-
No Independent Inquiry by Authority (¶18): The authority failed to conduct any independent investigation or collect corroborative evidence regarding the alleged ITC fraud.
-
Violation of Natural Justice (¶19): Relying solely on payment under protest without adjudicating the underlying tax demand is a gross procedural irregularity.
-
Portal Constraint Acknowledged (¶12): The inability to file appeal due to portal design, which showed nil demand, cannot deprive the petitioner of appellate remedy.
Judgment of the Court (¶20–¶21)
-
The impugned order dated 02.12.2023 passed under Section 74, levying interest and penalty, was quashed.
-
Respondent No. 4 was directed to issue a fresh DRC-07 indicating only the disputed tax amount (Rs. 1,11,45,134/-) to facilitate appeal on merits.
-
Liberty was granted to the petitioner to raise all legal and factual grounds in the appeal.
🧾 Between Fine Lines
-
Reversal of ITC under protest is not an admission of tax liability.
-
Authorities cannot levy interest and penalty without determining tax due through proper inquiry.
-
Procedural lapses such as denying appellate remedy via portal were found violative of natural justice.
-
Taxpayers have the right to contest ITC reversal even after making payment under protest.
-
The court reaffirmed the principle that form cannot override substance in GST proceedings.
📚 Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict/Usage |
|---|---|---|---|
| No specific case law cited | – | Court relied on principles of procedural fairness and interpretation of “under protest” from Black’s Law Dictionary | Used definition of “under protest” to reinforce taxpayer’s right to appeal post-payment |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




