Home Case Laws Rejection of ITC on ground of non-physical receipt of goods quashed; Patna...

Rejection of ITC on ground of non-physical receipt of goods quashed; Patna High Court held deemed delivery to end-consumer under dealer’s instructions satisfies Section 16(2)(b) of CGST Act.

0
329

Case:

M/s Utkrisht Trade Solutions Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. v. State of Bihar & Ors.
High Court of Judicature at Patna
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 17914 of 2023 (Lead Case, with connected CWJCs Nos. 470/2024, 17613/2023, 17636/2023, 17652/2023, 17654/2023, 17920/2023, 17922/2023, 18089/2023, 18297/2023, 18326/2023, 18394/2023, 18473/2023, 18497/2023, 18662/2023, 15/2024, 136/2024, 211/2024, 312/2024, 343/2024, 345/2024, 356/2024, 430/2024, 542/2024, 549/2024)
Category: Input Tax Credit (ITC) dispute
Date of Judgment: 11 April 2025
Relevant Sections: Section 16(2)(b), Section 31, Section 35, Section 54, Section 155 of the CGST Act, 2017 and corresponding BGST provisions; Rule 36 & Rule 89 of CGST Rules.

Facts (Paras 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8)

The petitioners, registered dealers in Bihar, had availed ITC under Section 16(2) of the CGST/BGST Acts. During inspection under Section 67, authorities alleged that output tax liability was discharged entirely through ITC without cash payment. Show cause notices under Section 73(1) were issued. Orders under Section 73(9) demanded tax, later confirmed in appeal.

The case of M/s Utkrisht Trade Solutions Pvt. Ltd. became the lead matter: goods purchased from suppliers were, on dealer’s instructions, delivered directly to end-consumers. Authorities denied ITC stating there was “no actual movement of goods” to the dealer, hence Section 16(2)(b) was not satisfied. Petitioners argued that GST had been paid to suppliers, suppliers remitted it to Government, and delivery to end-consumers at dealer’s instance amounted to receipt of goods. They relied on Circulars including No. 241/35/2024-GST (31.12.2024) clarifying “deemed receipt.”


Questions for Consideration (Paras 12, 13, 16, 19)

  • Whether receipt of goods under Section 16(2)(b) requires physical delivery to the dealer, or whether direct supply to end-consumers on dealer’s instructions suffices.

  • Whether denial of ITC was justified despite suppliers having paid GST to Government.

  • Applicability of precedents such as Aastha Enterprises v. State of Bihar and State of Karnataka v. Ecom Gill Trading Pvt. Ltd..


Observations (Paras 13–21)

  • Section 16(2)(b) provides that a registered person is deemed to have received goods if delivered to another person on his direction.

  • Circular No. 241/35/2024-GST clarified that physical possession is not mandatory; delivery to end-consumer under dealer’s instruction suffices.

  • The Court distinguished Aastha Enterprises, where supplier had not remitted tax, unlike present case.

  • The Supreme Court’s Ecom Gill Trading dealt with burden of proof under KVAT and not with interpretation of Section 16(2)(b) of CGST.

  • The authorities failed to appreciate documents and agreements showing dealer-supplier-consumer arrangements. Non-application of mind was evident.


Judgment (Paras 22, 23)

  • Impugned orders dated 14.01.2023 and 07.10.2023 rejecting ITC were set aside.

  • Matters remanded to the Deputy Commissioner of State Tax, Patliputra Circle, Patna for fresh consideration.

  • Authority directed to verify memorandum of understanding/agreements and proof of instructions for delivery to end-consumers.

  • If materials support petitioners, ITC shall be allowed; else a speaking order to be passed.

  • Exercise to be completed within six months.


Table of Case Law Referred

Case Citation Court Ratio / Relevance
Aastha Enterprises v. State of Bihar CWJC No. 10359 of 2023 (Patna HC) Patna High Court Denial of ITC upheld where supplier had not remitted tax to Govt. Distinguished in present case.
State of Karnataka v. Ecom Gill Trading Pvt. Ltd. 2023 SCC OnLine SC 248 Supreme Court Held burden of proving correctness of ITC lies on purchasing dealer; not directly applicable to Section 16(2)(b) CGST.
SAJ Food Products Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Bihar CWJC No. 15465 of 2022 Patna High Court Concerned with pre-deposit & non-constitution of GST Tribunal; not applicable to physical receipt of goods issue.

Between Fine Lines

This judgment clarifies that physical delivery of goods to a dealer is not essential for availing ITC under GST. If goods are delivered directly to end-consumers on dealer’s instructions and tax is duly paid, ITC cannot be denied. Businesses following modern supply models like drop-shipments now have judicial backing, provided proper documentation and agreements are maintained.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY