Home Case Laws Request to substitute the provisional attachment from movable property to immovable property...

Request to substitute the provisional attachment from movable property to immovable property under GST.

0
412

Utkarsh Ispat LLP v. State of Gujarat

High Court of Gujarat

R/Special Civil Application No. 16063 of 2022

Category: Provisional Attachment under Section 83, Input Tax Credit

Date of Judgment: 16 December 2022

Relevant Sections: Section 83, 90, 137 of CGST Act, Rule 159(5) of CGST Rules

Takeaway: “When Partners Pay the Price: Limits of Liability in Provisional Attachment”

 

Facts of the Case (¶1–¶5)

  1. Nature of Business: Utkarsh Ispat LLP is a registered LLP engaged in manufacturing and supplying Mild Steel Billets (¶1).
  2. Search & Attachment: Based on investigations revealing that some suppliers issued invoices without supplying goods, searches were conducted at the petitioner’s business and residences (¶3.1). On 25-11-2021, provisional attachment orders under Form DRC-22 were issued attaching various properties including FDs, bank accounts, and personal assets of partners (¶3.2–3.4).
  3. Legal Challenge: Petitioner challenged the attachments via multiple writ petitions. Some attachments were quashed by the Court on 27-01-2022 (¶3.8).
  4. Subsequent Requests: Petitioner made repeated requests (dated 28-03-2022, 21-04-2022) offering immovable property in lieu of FDs and bank accounts to lift the attachment (¶3.9–3.11), relying on CBIC Circular dated 23-02-2021 (¶3.9).
  5. Rejection by Authorities: The offer was rejected citing that the GIDC plot was leasehold and the residential plot belonged to a partner, not the LLP, and was previously quashed from attachment by Court (¶3.11–4.3).

 

Questions in Consideration (¶6)

  • Whether the petitioner can substitute provisionally attached FDs and bank accounts with immovable property under CBIC Circular guidelines?
  • Whether the personal property of a partner can be provisionally attached under Section 83 of the CGST Act?

 

Observations of the Court

  1. Section 83 Scope: The power of provisional attachment applies only to the “taxable person” under Section 2(107) CGST Act. An LLP is distinct from its partners, and hence, personal property of partners cannot be attached under Section 83 (¶7, ¶27).
  2. Misapplication of Section 90: The Department erred in invoking Section 90 CGST Act. Liability under Section 90 or Section 25 of the Partnership Act becomes enforceable only after assessment is finalized. Attachment prior to adjudication is impermissible (¶27).
  3. CBIC Guidelines Applicable: CBIC Circular (23-02-2021) permits substitution of attached movable property with immovable property if the latter is unencumbered and of sufficient value (¶6, ¶9).
  4. Property Valuation: The petitioner submitted valuation reports showing the residential plot is unencumbered and worth Rs. 13.01 crores, satisfying the requirement under the circular (¶10–10.1).
  5. Substituted Security Accepted: Court allowed substitution of immovable property (except for Rs. 2.24 crore FD) for release of other provisionally attached FDs and bank accounts (¶11).

Judgment of the Court (¶11)

  • Petition allowed partially.
  • Directed release of all provisionally attached FDs and bank accounts except Rs. 2,24,99,844/-.
  • The immovable property offered by the petitioner to be treated as substituted attachment.
  • Fresh order of attachment, if any, can be independently challenged.
  • The petitioner must not mortgage or alienate the substituted property until further orders.

 

Between Fine Lines

  • A partner’s personal property cannot be attached under Section 83 unless the partner is a “taxable person”.
  • Immovable property can be substituted for attached movable assets under CBIC Circular if unencumbered and sufficient in value.
  • Court upheld the distinction between LLPs and their partners under GST law.
  • Authorities must adhere strictly to CBIC guidelines for provisional attachments.
  • Only one fixed deposit was allowed to continue under attachment, rest were ordered to be released.

 

Summary of Referred Cases

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Utkarsh Ispat LLP v. State of Gujarat [SCA No. 188 of 2022, decided 27-1-2022] Earlier case quashing attachment of some immovable properties and sundry debtors Provisional attachments partly quashed, personal properties excluded
Kapurchand Shrimal v. TRO, Hyderabad AIR 1969 SC 682 Assessee alone can be treated as defaulter; third-party assets cannot be attached Attachment of personal property without liability determination disallowed
Her Highness Maharani Mandalsa Devi v. H. Ramnarain (P) Ltd. 65 BLR 31 A firm is not a legal entity distinct from partners; liability is joint and several Clarified that a firm’s identity is not separate for liabilities

LEAVE A REPLY