Home Case Laws Payment made under coercion and without giving acknowledgement were not considered as...

Payment made under coercion and without giving acknowledgement were not considered as voluntary payments.

0
256

Case Title: Vallabh Textiles v. Senior Intelligence Officer

Court: High Court of Delhi

Petition Number: W.P. (C) No. 9834 of 2022

Relevant Sections: Sections 67(5), 73(5), 74(5), 76(6) of CGST Act, 2017; Rule 142(1A), 142(2) of CGST Rules, 2017

Category: Recovery during Investigation/Search

Date of Judgement: 20th December 2022

Takeaway: “Voluntariness under Coercion – Dissecting GST Recovery during Search Operations”

Facts of the Case [¶1–21]:

  1. A search was conducted at Vallabh Textiles’ unregistered premises from 3:30 PM on 16.02.2022 to 9:30 AM on 17.02.2022 [¶3–4].
  2. During the search, the petitioner deposited ₹1.80 crores in four tranches between 1:28 AM and 7:03 AM on 17.02.2022 through Form GST DRC-03 [¶2, 33.1].
  3. It was alleged by the Department that Vallabh Textiles sold garments worth ₹149.90 crores for two third-party firms (Empire Apparels and Navrang Enterprises) in cash and received ₹7.5 crores commission, also in cash [¶10–11].
  4. The department seized ledgers, laptops, and documents allegedly showing clandestine transactions [¶14–15].
  5. The petitioner contended that the deposit was made under coercion, statements were forcibly obtained, and proper procedures under GST law were not followed [¶22.2–22.12].

 

Questions in Consideration:

  1. Whether the deposit of ₹1,80,10,000 during the search operation was voluntary or made under coercion? [¶1]
  2. Whether the proper procedures under CGST Act and Rules were followed in accepting such deposit? [¶22–23]

 

Observation of Court:

  1. The search concluded at 9:30 AM on 17.02.2022, but the deposits were made during early morning hours while the search was ongoing, which questions the voluntariness [¶34–35].
  2. No acknowledgment in Form GST DRC-04 was issued, as required under Rule 142(2) of the CGST Rules [¶32.1, 36].
  3. CBIC’s Instruction No. 01/2022-2023, following the Gujarat HC judgment in Bhumi Associate, was violated, particularly the instruction not to accept payments during the search [¶37–39.2].
  4. Even if payment is voluntary, it should be done after the search ends and officers leave to allow legal counsel; that opportunity was not given [¶41.1].
  5. Retraction of the statements was not delayed enough to dilute the petitioner’s credibility, especially in light of procedural lapses [¶40.1].

 

Judgement of Court:

  1. The deposit of ₹1,80,10,000 lacked voluntariness and was held to be extracted under coercion [¶42].
  2. The court directed the department to refund the entire amount with 6% simple interest from 17.02.2022 until the date of refund [¶43–45].
  3. CBIC was also directed to align Instruction No. 01/2022-2023 dated 25.05.2022 with Bhumi Associate guidelines [¶46].

 

Between Fine Lines (Simple Summary in 5 Lines):

  • The Court ruled that tax deposits made during a GST search were not voluntary.
  • The search concluded after the deposits were made, indicating coercion.
  • Mandatory procedures like DRC-04 acknowledgment were not followed.
  • Recovery during searches is not permitted unless post-search and voluntary.
  • Refund of ₹1.8 crores with 6% interest was ordered within 10 days.

Summary of Referred Cases:

Name of Case Citation Summary Verdict
Bhumi Associate v. UOI [2021] 124 taxmann.com 429 (Gujarat HC) Directed no recovery during GST search, even voluntary deposits must follow procedure Binding directions issued; relied upon

LEAVE A REPLY