Home Case Laws Section 16(2)(c) Valid but Not to Be Invoked Mechanically; Supplier’s Default or...

Section 16(2)(c) Valid but Not to Be Invoked Mechanically; Supplier’s Default or Retrospective Cancellation Alone Cannot Deny Purchaser’s ITC: Punjab and Haryana High Court

0
216

1. Title of the Case

Case Title Shaurya Alloys Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Punjab and Another, and connected matters (a bunch of 424 writ petitions)
Case Number CWP-34296-2024 (O&M) and connected cases
Court and Bench High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh (Division Bench); Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Ashwani Kumar Mishra, Chief Justice and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rohit Kapoor (judgment authored by the Chief Justice)
Date of Order 01.10.2026 (reserved on 21.08.2026)
Relevant Provisions Sections 16(2)(c), 29(2), 41, 42 (since omitted), 73, 74, 74A, 75(4), 75(6), 75(12), 76, 79 and 155 of the CGST Act, 2017; Rules 36, 37A and 88C of the CGST Rules, 2017; Articles 14, 19(1)(g), 21, 265 and 300A of the Constitution of India

2. Summary of the Judgment

Facts of the Case. A bunch of 424 writ petitions, led by Shaurya Alloys Pvt. Ltd., challenged notices, orders and registration cancellations denying or reversing input tax credit (ITC) of purchasing dealers under Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act, 2017, mostly because the selling dealer had not deposited tax or its registration was later cancelled, often retrospectively (paras 1 to 4, 88 and 89). The petitioners pointed out that the matching mechanism through GSTR-2, GSTR-3 and Section 42 was never operationalised, that Section 41 was substituted and Sections 42 and 43 omitted with effect from 01.10.2022, and that Rule 37A for re-availment came only from 26.12.2022 (paras 19 to 28).

Issues for Determination. Whether Section 16(2)(c), read with Section 155, is ultra vires as compelling a purchaser to perform an impossible act (lex non cogit ad impossibilia), and whether it should be read down to confine liability to cases of fraud, collusion or non-existent suppliers; and what obligation rests on a purchaser who has paid tax to the supplier but has no means to verify its deposit (paras 1, 2 and 68).

Findings and Observations of the Court. Section 16(2)(c) was designed as part of an integrated matching scheme and cannot be applied as a standalone provision (paras 74 to 77). Section 76, which addresses tax collected but not paid, cannot be rendered otiose by indiscriminate invocation of Section 16(2)(c) (paras 79 to 82). Before Rule 37A, no re-availment mechanism existed (paras 83 and 97). Fraud, collusion, non-existent suppliers or non-receipt of goods stand on a different footing (para 87). Bound by Maruti Enterprises (Gujarat High Court), affirmed in Bhandari Scrap Traders (Supreme Court), the Court declined to read the provision down (para 98). In a Section 74 notice, the facts showing fraud must appear in the notice itself, and the seller’s fraud is not the purchaser’s fraud (paras 100 to 102).

Verdict and Basis of the Judgment. The vires challenge was repelled (para 98), but the Court laid down binding guidelines for invoking Section 16(2)(c) (paras 99 and 103): no routine reliance on supplier default or retrospective cancellation; recorded satisfaction on the nature of default and recovery action against the supplier; a direct link between purchaser and supplier; full disclosure of relied-upon material; no double realisation of tax; period-wise application of the law; no cancellation of the purchaser’s registration on that ground alone; hearing, cross-examination and reasoned orders. Petitions were disposed of with liberty to reply within eight weeks, fresh adjudication of passed orders and no coercive recovery meanwhile (para 105).

Analysis of the Judgment. The ruling keeps the provision intact in deference to Bhandari Scrap Traders, yet supplies the safeguards on which that validity rests. It turns the inquiry first to the defaulting supplier and the Department’s recovery tools.

Legal Takeaway. Purchasers facing ITC denial for supplier default should insist that the notice discloses the supplier’s default, recovery action and a direct link to the purchaser, and should prove genuineness through invoices, e-way bills, transport and payment records.

3. Tabular Summary

Sl. No. Case Title Case No. / Citation Court / Bench Date of Order Facts & Issue Verdict & Basis of Judgment Key Legal Takeaway
1 Shaurya Alloys Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Punjab and Another (with connected matters) CWP-34296-2024 (O&M) and connected cases (424 writ petitions) Punjab and Haryana High Court; Ashwani Kumar Mishra, CJ and Rohit Kapoor, J 01.10.2026 ITC denied or reversed under Section 16(2)(c) because suppliers did not deposit tax or their registrations were cancelled retrospectively. Issue: vires of Section 16(2)(c) and Section 155, or reading down to fraud cases. Vires upheld following Maruti Enterprises and Bhandari Scrap Traders; reading down declined. But the provision must be applied with the statutory scheme (Sections 74, 75(12), 76, Rule 37A); 14 guidelines issued; matters remitted for fresh, reasoned adjudication with no coercive action meanwhile. Supplier default or retrospective cancellation alone cannot found ITC denial; the SCN must disclose supplier default, recovery action and a direct link to the purchaser; the seller’s fraud is not the purchaser’s fraud.

Download the judgment: Download PDF 

LEAVE A REPLY