Godavari Commodities Ltd. v. Union of India
High Court of Jharkhand
W.P. (T) No. 1786 of 2019
Category: Interest on delayed payment, Natural Justice
Date of Judgment: 05 December 2019
Relevant Sections: Section 50(1), Section 73(1) of the CGST Act, 2017
Facts of the Case
[Para 2–3]
Godavari Commodities Ltd. was served with a letter dated 06.02.2019 from the Superintendent of CGST, demanding ₹11,58,643/- towards interest on delayed GST payment. No show-cause notice was issued before this demand. Following this, the petitioner’s bank account was frozen and later defrozen upon payment.
[Para 4]
The petitioner contended that issuing such a demand without a show-cause notice under Section 73(1) of the CGST Act is unlawful and violative of natural justice.
[Para 5–6]
The department argued that since the tax and some interest were already paid (though belatedly), and the dispute only involved short-paid interest, Section 73(1) did not apply. Instead, Section 50(1) governed the case, and no show-cause was necessary.
Questions in Consideration
[Para 7]
Whether the issuance of a direct recovery demand for interest on delayed tax payment, without issuing a show-cause notice under Section 73(1), is valid under the CGST Act, especially when penal consequences like freezing of bank accounts are involved?
Observations of the Court
[Para 7]
The Court noted that even though the tax and partial interest were paid, the liability of interest on delayed payment still falls under non-payment/short payment, attracting Section 73(1). Therefore, a show-cause notice was mandatory.
[Para 7]
Further, the Court emphasized the basic principle of natural justice—that penal or coercive actions, like freezing accounts or monetary recovery, cannot be taken without giving an opportunity of hearing.
[Para 9]
The Court treated the demand letter as a deemed show-cause notice and directed the adjudicating authority to give a hearing and pass a reasoned order.
Judgment of the Court
[Para 9–11]
The High Court held that:
- The demand letter dated 06.02.2019 will be treated as a show-cause notice under Section 73(1).
- The petitioner must be heard before confirming liability.
- If on adjudication it is found that no interest was payable, the recovered amount must be refunded with statutory interest.
- The adjudicating authority must pass a reasoned order within 3 months.
Between Fine Lines
- Recovery of interest on delayed GST payment must comply with Section 73(1) and natural justice.
- No recovery action (like freezing bank accounts) is permissible without notice and hearing.
- Even if the liability appears admitted, the taxpayer deserves adjudication.
- The demand letter was construed as a show-cause to preserve procedural fairness.
- Refund with interest is directed if adjudication rules in petitioner’s favour.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| None cited directly in judgment | — | — | — |
Takeaway
“Interest Recovery Without Notice: A Breach of Natural Justice”




