Kushal Ltd. v. Union of India
High Court of Gujarat | Special Civil Application No. 19533 of 2019
Date of Judgment: 17 December 2019
Relevant Section: Section 83 of the CGST Act, 2017
Category: Provisional Attachment
Facts of the Case [¶1–7]
- Kushal Ltd., a GST-registered company engaged in the manufacture and trading of paper and commodities, claimed ITC on purchases and paid tax liabilities accordingly.
- A search under Section 67 was conducted on 27.09.2018, where the department questioned the genuineness of transactions done on “as is where is” basis due to the lack of goods movement.
- Despite evidence of tax deposits in GSTR-2A, authorities arrested the second petitioner on 01.04.2019 under Section 69.
- No show cause notice under Sections 73/74 was issued thereafter, yet on 18.10.2019, the department provisionally attached the bank accounts under Section 83 without serving some of the orders.
Questions in Consideration
- Whether the department’s invocation of Section 83 to provisionally attach bank accounts is valid in absence of pending proceedings under Sections 62, 63, 64, 67, 73, or 74 of the CGST Act? [¶13–14]
- Whether proceedings under Section 67 can be deemed to be “pending” merely because investigation is ongoing, even when no fresh action under that section has been initiated? [¶12–14]
Observations of the Court
- Section 83 can only be invoked when proceedings under Sections 62, 63, 64, 67, 73, or 74 are pending. [¶14]
- The search was conducted on 27.09.2018, and although the investigation continued, no active proceedings under Section 67 were pending at the time of the provisional attachment. [¶12–13]
- Mere continuation of inquiry post-search does not qualify as pendency of Section 67 proceedings. Thus, the basic precondition under Section 83 was not met. [¶14]
- The petitioners’ claim that taxes were duly paid and credit was legally availed was left open for consideration in separate appropriate proceedings. [¶15]
Judgment of the Court [¶17]
The High Court quashed the provisional attachment orders dated 18.10.2019 issued under Section 83, declaring them without legal authority in the absence of any pending proceedings under the relevant sections. The Court directed immediate release of all attached bank accounts.
Between Fine Lines
- Provisional attachment under Section 83 is not permissible unless proceedings under specific sections (62, 63, 64, 67, 73, or 74) are pending.
- Investigation alone, without ongoing formal proceedings under these sections, does not empower authorities to attach bank accounts.
- Attachment orders passed without jurisdiction are liable to be quashed.
- Taxpayers must be served with attachment orders for procedural fairness.
- Legality of ITC claims must be adjudicated in proper proceedings, not assumed in attachment orders.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Vishwanath Realtor v. State of Gujarat | [2015] 58 taxmann.com 270 | Held that for provisional attachment, authorities must form opinion based on tangible material. | Formation of opinion is mandatory |
Takeaway:
“Attachment without Anchor: No Provisional Attachment without Pending Proceedings under GST”




