Case Title: Anant Jignesh Shah v. Union of India
Court: High Court of Gujarat
Petition No.: R/Special Civil Application No. 12712 of 2020
Category of Dispute: Detention and Confiscation – E-way Bill Validity and Transport of Goods
Date of Judgment: 06 November 2020
Relevant Sections: Sections 129(1), 130 – Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017
Facts of the Case (¶2–4)
- The petitioner, a registered trader in pan masala under CGST, ordered goods worth ₹35,74,155 from Atharva Enterprises, Madhya Pradesh. The goods were dispatched from Ujjain to Ahmedabad on 8 September 2020 (¶2).
- A valid e-way bill was generated for the transit (valid from 8-9-2020 to 13-9-2020) (¶3).
- On 12 September 2020, the vehicle was intercepted by the mobile squad of the tax department and was detained under Section 129(1) via Form GST MOV-06 on 13 September 2020. A show cause notice in Form GST MOV-10 under Section 130 was issued on 15 September 2020 (¶3–4).
Questions in Consideration (¶6–9)
- Whether the goods and conveyance were transported in contravention of the CGST Act and Rules justifying detention under Section 129(1)?
- Whether mere suspicion of prior use of the same e-way bill constitutes a valid basis to invoke confiscation proceedings under Section 130?
Observation of the Court (¶6–9)
- The show cause notice was based on an allegation that goods were moved twice using the same e-way bill, with reference to toll plaza data and prior movement of the vehicle (¶6).
- The Court found the allegation speculative and based purely on suspicion without any concrete evidence or violation of a specific provision of the Act or Rules (¶7–8).
- The Assistant Government Pleader fairly admitted that there was no contravention at the time of transit; the suspicion of tax evasion was hypothetical (¶8).
- The Court held that a notice under Section 130 cannot be based on conjecture. A prima facie contravention is necessary before invoking confiscation (¶9).
Judgment of the Court (¶10)
- The High Court quashed the show cause notice dated 15 September 2020 (Form GST MOV-10) under Section 130.
- It allowed the writ petition and directed the release of the goods and conveyance.
- The Court clarified that the authority may conduct a separate inquiry if required for any other transaction.
Between Fine Lines
- Goods cannot be detained or confiscated solely based on suspicions without tangible evidence of contravention.
- Proper procedural safeguards and evidence are necessary under Sections 129 and 130 before initiating detention/confiscation.
- Courts will intervene where administrative action is based on assumptions rather than legal violations.
- Valid e-way bill and undisputed transit are strong defenses in detention cases.
- Authorities must not misuse powers under GST law for mere suspicion of tax evasion.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Case Name | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| None cited in this order | — | — | — |
Takeaway:
“E-way Suspicion Doesn’t Justify Detention”




