Home Case Laws Show Cause Notice issued with improper or incomplete information is not valid.

Show Cause Notice issued with improper or incomplete information is not valid.

0
511

Case Title: Jaiprakash Thekedar v. Commissioner, Commercial Taxes

Court: High Court of Allahabad

Petition Number: Writ Tax No. 1511 of 2022

Category: Cancellation of Registration under GST

Date of Judgement: 22 December 2022

Relevant Sections: Section 29(2), Section 169 of the CGST/UPGST Act; Rule 22(1) of UPGST Rules

Takeaway: A show cause notice without a hearing date is no notice at all

 

Facts of the Case

[¶2–3]

  • The petitioner challenged the cancellation of his GST registration under the UPGST Act, 2017.
  • A show cause notice (SCN) dated 31.08.2019 was issued for non-filing of returns for six months.
  • The SCN required a response within 7 days and threatened ex parte action in case of default.
  • However, the final cancellation order dated 21.09.2019 falsely stated that no reply had been received, despite the petitioner submitting a response on 10.09.2019.

[¶4]

  • The petitioner contended that the SCN was not properly served and did not specify the date and time for personal hearing.
  • He argued that the absence of a hearing date amounted to a violation of natural justice.

 

Question(s) in Consideration

[¶5–6]

  • Whether a show cause notice for cancellation of registration under Section 29(2) of the Act is valid if it does not specify the date and time for personal hearing?
  • Whether mere uploading of SCN on the common portal satisfies the requirement of service under Section 169?

 

Observation of the Court

[¶6–8]

  • Rule 22(1) mandates issuance of Form GST REG-17, which must include a specific date and time for personal hearing.
  • The SCN served on the petitioner did not comply with the prescribed format as it lacked this essential detail.
  • The Court held that this omission amounts to a violation of the right to be heard under the principles of natural justice.
  • The authorities’ reliance on Section 169 (service via common portal) was immaterial when a statutory requirement under Rule 22 was not met.

 

Judgement of the Court

[¶9]

  • The Court quashed the cancellation order as being illegal, void, and null in law.
  • Liberty was granted to the department to initiate fresh proceedings in accordance with the law and proper procedure.

 

Between Fine Lines

  • The High Court reaffirmed that natural justice cannot be dispensed with in tax proceedings.
  • A show cause notice must clearly mention the hearing date and time to provide a fair opportunity to respond.
  • Uploading an incomplete notice on the portal does not suffice.
  • Any order passed on such defective notice is unsustainable.
  • The department must strictly adhere to the prescribed format and procedure.

 Summary of Referred Cases

Case Name Citation Summary Verdict
Pushpam Reality v. State Tax Officer [2022] 136 taxmann.com 195 / 91 GST 417 Service of SCN only via portal is not valid if technical issues exist; must ensure due hearing Relied upon by petitioner to support claim

LEAVE A REPLY