Case Reference
Goverdhandham Estate Private Limited v. State of Rajasthan & Ors.
Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench
D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 16702/2023
Judgment dated: 17.01.2024
Category: Input Tax Credit (ITC) – Blocked Credits & Jurisdictional Validity of SCN
Relevant Sections: Sections 17(5), 50, 61, 65, 66, 67, 73, 74 of CGST/RGST Act, 2017; Rule 99 of CGST Rules, 2017
Facts (Paras 2–8)
The petitioner, engaged in hotel operations and registered under GST, filed monthly GSTR-3B for FY 2017-18. On scrutiny under Section 61, the Department issued ASMT-10 notice (01.09.2023) alleging ineligible ITC on elevators and air-conditioners, treating them as blocked credits under Section 17(5). The petitioner replied (15.09.2023) that these items constituted “plant and machinery” used in business, hence ITC was admissible.
Despite the pending reply, the Department issued SCN under Section 73 (21.09.2023) demanding reversal of ITC of ₹18,44,884/- with interest. Later, the Department itself issued ASMT-12 (29.09.2023) accepting the petitioner’s reply as satisfactory, yet enclosed remarks that the SCN would continue to hold validity. This contradiction led the petitioner to challenge the SCN and the enclosure to ASMT-12 before the High Court.
Questions of Law (Paras 9–12)
-
Whether initiation of proceedings under Section 73 is permissible without first considering the explanation submitted in response to discrepancies raised under Section 61.
-
Whether acceptance of reply under Section 61 through ASMT-12 bars further proceedings under Section 73 based on the same discrepancies.
-
Whether the Department can retain jurisdiction by issuing contradictory enclosures despite accepting the explanation.
Observations (Paras 14–28)
-
Section 61 provides a structured mechanism: once discrepancies are pointed out, the taxpayer’s explanation must be considered. If satisfactory, no further action can be taken; if unsatisfactory, only then proceedings under Sections 65, 66, 67, 73 or 74 may be initiated.
-
The Court noted that the petitioner’s explanation on “plant and machinery” was never considered in the SCN under Section 73 (Para 20–22). The SCN merely reproduced Section 17(5) without reasoning.
-
Issuance of ASMT-12 dated 29.09.2023 confirmed that the explanation was accepted as satisfactory (Para 26). Once accepted, sub-section (2) of Section 61 mandates “no further action”. The Department’s attempt to retain jurisdiction through the enclosure was termed a misconceived notion of law (Para 28).
-
Reliance on Nagarjuna Agro Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. (Allahabad HC) was rejected as distinguishable because that case did not involve scrutiny under Section 61, whereas the present case arose directly from discrepancies in returns (Para 23).
Judgment (Paras 29–30)
The High Court held that:
-
Invocation of Section 73 without considering the explanation under Section 61 was illegal.
-
Once ASMT-12 accepted the reply, no further action could survive.
-
The show cause notice dated 21.09.2023 and enclosure to ASMT-12 dated 29.09.2023 were quashed as unsustainable in law.
-
Petition allowed. No order as to costs.
Table of Cases Referred
| Case | Court & Petition No. | Issue | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nagarjuna Agro Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. v. State of U.P. & Anr. | Allahabad High Court, Writ Tax No.336/2023 | Whether scrutiny under Section 61 is mandatory before action under Section 74 | Held that Sections 61 and 74 operate independently; notice under Section 61 not mandatory before invoking Section 74. Distinguished in present case as facts were different. |
Between Fine Lines
For businesses, this ruling underscores that once discrepancies raised under Section 61 are explained satisfactorily and accepted, the Department cannot pursue parallel recovery under Section 73 on the same grounds. It reinforces the principle of certainty and protection from double jeopardy in GST proceedings, ensuring that departmental officers must apply their mind and record reasoning before invoking coercive jurisdiction.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




