The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Indore Bench, in Smt. Poonam Rathore v. Income Tax Officer, Sehore, has allowed the assessee’s appeal concerning an addition arising from the purchase of agricultural land during Assessment Year 2011-12. The Tribunal examined whether the higher value appearing in departmental information could be adopted instead of the actual consideration recorded in the sale deed for determining the assessee’s investment. The order was pronounced on 10 July 2026 in ITA No. 302/Ind/2026.
Background of the Case
The assessee was a non-filer and proceedings under Sections 144/147 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 were initiated on the basis of Non-PAN AIR information indicating purchase of immovable property valued at Rs. 46,78,800. The Assessing Officer consequently assessed the assessee’s income at that amount through an ex parte assessment order dated 21 December 2018.
The property in question was agricultural land purchased jointly by the assessee and two other persons. During the appellate proceedings, it was established that the assessee held a one-third share in the property. The CIT(A), relying upon the Assessing Officer’s remand report, therefore reduced the addition from Rs. 46,78,800 to Rs. 15,59,600, representing one-third of the value initially adopted by the Assessing Officer.
The assessee, however, contended before the Tribunal that the agricultural land had actually been purchased on 28 March 2011 for Rs. 24 lakh, and that her one-third share in the actual consideration was only about Rs. 8 lakh. She further relied upon documents concerning ancestral agricultural holdings and agricultural produce receipts to explain the source of investment.
Actual Purchase Consideration versus Stamp Duty Value
The principal issue before the Tribunal was whether the investment could be quantified by reference to the higher value of Rs. 46,78,800, or whether the actual sale consideration of Rs. 24 lakh recorded for the property should govern the determination.
The Tribunal noted that the sale deed dated 28 March 2011 recorded consideration of Rs. 24 lakh for the agricultural land and that the assessee was one of three purchasers.
A significant aspect of the ruling was the Tribunal’s examination of Section 56(2)(vii)(b). It observed that, on the relevant date of purchase, the provision dealing with acquisition of immovable property for consideration lower than its stamp duty value in the form later introduced by the Finance Act, 2013 was not applicable. According to the Tribunal, the relevant amendment came into effect from 1 April 2014.
Consequently, the Tribunal held that for the transaction dated 28 March 2011, the actual purchase price of Rs. 24 lakh “holds the field”, rather than Rs. 46,78,800 adopted on the basis of the higher property value. The assessee’s one-third share was accordingly determined at Rs. 8 lakh.
Source of Investment from Agricultural Income
The Tribunal also considered the assessee’s explanation regarding the source of the Rs. 8 lakh investment. The assessee had placed material in the paper book relating to agricultural holdings and agricultural income, including documents concerning ancestral agricultural land and receipts from Krishi Mandi.
The Tribunal found that sufficient evidence regarding the agricultural holdings and agricultural income had been placed on record. It also noted that the Departmental Representative had not questioned the veracity of those documents.
On these facts, the Tribunal accepted the explanation regarding the source of the investment and set aside the order of the CIT(A). The assessee’s appeal was consequently allowed.
Key Legal Principle
The ruling demonstrates that an addition for investment in immovable property cannot automatically be quantified by substituting a higher stamp or departmental valuation for the actual purchase consideration without considering the statutory provisions applicable in the relevant assessment year.
For the transaction before it, the ITAT specifically held that the subsequent form of Section 56(2)(vii)(b), dealing with property acquired for consideration below stamp duty value, was not applicable to the purchase made on 28 March 2011. Therefore, the actual consideration of Rs. 24 lakh was adopted, and only the assessee’s one-third share of Rs. 8 lakh was considered.
The decision is also relevant from an evidentiary perspective because the Tribunal considered the material relating to agricultural holdings and agricultural income while determining whether the assessee had satisfactorily explained the source of the investment.
Why This Judgment Matters
The decision is relevant for tax professionals dealing with unexplained investment additions under Section 69, particularly where immovable property has been purchased jointly and the tax authorities seek to rely upon a value higher than the recorded consideration. It also highlights the importance of applying property valuation provisions according to the law prevailing in the relevant assessment year and of examining documentary evidence relating to the source of investment before sustaining an addition.
The complete judgment should be referred to for the detailed factual background, submissions of the parties, statutory discussion and reasoning adopted by the ITAT Indore Bench.




