The Supreme Court, in Income Tax Officer, Ward 2(1), Chandigarh & Others v. Tej Partap Singh, considered a large batch of matters concerning reassessment proceedings under the Income-tax Act. The lead matter arose from the judgment dated 8 April 2025 passed by the Punjab and Haryana High Court in CWP No. 10149 of 2025. The proceedings before the Supreme Court were registered as SLP (Civil) Diary No. 2196 of 2026.
The matter was heard on 6 April 2026 by a Bench comprising the Chief Justice of India, Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice Joymalya Bagchi. The order passed by the Court was procedural and did not finally adjudicate the validity of the reassessment notices or determine the substantive legal issues involved in the batch.
Question of Limitation for Assessment Year 2015-16
At the outset of the hearing, the learned Additional Solicitor General informed the Court that certain matters included in the batch related to Assessment Year 2015-16 and that reassessment in those matters appeared to be barred by limitation.
The Additional Solicitor General sought time to verify the stand taken on behalf of the assessees. The Supreme Court granted two weeks for such verification. The Court also permitted counsel appearing for the assessees to provide details of any other cases relating to Assessment Year 2015-16 so that their limitation status could similarly be examined.
The direction is significant because limitation is a jurisdictional requirement governing the initiation of reassessment proceedings. Before proceeding further with the merits of the connected cases, the Court considered it appropriate that matters which may already be time-barred should be separately identified and verified.
Matters De-tagged for Separate Consideration
The Supreme Court directed that the identified Assessment Year 2015-16 matters be de-tagged from the principal batch and listed separately on 4 May 2026. The remaining connected matters were directed to be posted on 10 April 2026 at 2:00 p.m.
The order therefore does not declare every reassessment proceeding relating to Assessment Year 2015-16 to be invalid. It records the Revenue’s preliminary statement that reassessment in certain identified matters may be time-barred and requires verification of the factual and legal position before those matters are considered separately.
Importance of the Order
The proceedings are relevant for taxpayers, advocates and tax professionals handling reassessment disputes involving older assessment years. They underline the necessity of examining the applicable statutory limitation period, the date of the reassessment notice, the assessment year involved and any statutory extension or exclusion of time before addressing the merits of the alleged income escaping assessment.
The order is particularly important in batch litigation where connected petitions may arise from different assessment years and factual situations. By directing segregation and verification of the Assessment Year 2015-16 cases, the Supreme Court ensured that matters potentially barred by time are not considered indiscriminately with cases governed by different limitation periods.




