Case Title: Union of India v. Bharat Forge Ltd.
Court: Supreme Court of India
Petition Number: Civil Appeal No. 5294 of 2022
Category: GST – Classification, Tender Evaluation
Date of Judgment: 16 August 2022
Relevant Sections: Article 14, 19(1)(g) of Constitution; Sections 9, 59, 60, 96, 97, 103, 168 of CGST Act, 2017; Clause 2.7.6, 2.8.6.2, 2.9.2 of Tender Document
Facts of the Case [Paras 4–6, 32, 36–38, 51–52]
- A global tender was issued by Diesel Locomotive Works (DLW), Varanasi on 11.04.2019 for the supply of turbo wheel impeller assemblies. Bharat Forge Ltd. (writ petitioner) emerged as L4, while others quoting a lower GST rate (5%) emerged as L1 to L3. Bharat Forge quoted 18% GST, leading to a price disadvantage and filing of a writ petition alleging unfair tendering practice due to non-specification of the correct GST rate and HSN Code.
- Bharat Forge argued that the correct GST rate should have been 18% as per HSN Code 84148030, and that the absence of such specification in the NIT allowed others to underquote unfairly, sabotaging the level playing field and the Make in India policy.
Question(s) in Consideration [Paras 2–3, 6–7, 31–32]
- Whether the failure to specify the correct HSN Code and GST rate in the tender violated principles of fairness and level playing field under Article 14 and Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution.
- Whether a Writ of Mandamus can be issued directing the tendering authority to seek GST classification clarification from GST authorities and specify it in the tender document.
Observations of the Court
[Paras 15–19, 31, 37–39, 43–47, 55–59, 61]
- The Supreme Court held that no statutory or public duty existed requiring the tendering authority to specify the correct HSN Code. The responsibility lies with the bidder to quote correct tax rates and comply with GST laws [Paras 37–38].
- Clause 2.9.2 allowed bidders to quote inclusive prices without tax breakup. Thus, there was no legal uncertainty justifying judicial interference [Para 39].
- The Court criticized the High Court for issuing a direction tantamount to a Mandamus without a statutory basis. It reiterated that tender terms can be interfered with only when arbitrary, mala fide, or discriminatory, which was not the case here [Paras 19, 39].
- The Make in India policy could not override clear tender terms. Since “local content” calculation excluded domestic indirect taxes, non-specification of HSN Code did not violate the policy [Para 55].
- Including the HSN Code by the purchaser would also create practical difficulties and was beyond the tendering authority’s role. Sections 59 and 60 imposed self-assessment responsibility on the supplier, not the purchaser [Paras 47–48].
Judgment of the Court [Paras 61–62]
- The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the High Court’s judgment, and declined to impose a mandatory duty on the tendering authority to specify the HSN Code or seek clarification from GST authorities.
- However, to prevent GST evasion, the Court directed that a copy of the awarded contract must be forwarded to the supplier’s jurisdictional GST officer, and bidders must furnish their assessing officer’s details in their bids [Para 61].
Between Fine Lines
- The Court held that GST classification responsibility lies solely with the supplier, not the procuring entity.
- Tender terms allowing tax-inclusive or exclusive quotes do not mandate mentioning HSN Codes.
- A Writ of Mandamus cannot be issued without a clear statutory or public duty.
- Make in India preferences must be applied in line with existing tender and tax structures.
- Purchasers must, however, forward contract details to GST officers to ensure compliance.
Summary of Referred Cases
| Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| Reliance Energy Ltd. v. MSRDC | (2007) 8 SCC 1 | Discussed level playing field in tendering and public interest in transparent state contracts | Distinguished by SC; facts not apposite |
| Andi Mukta Trust v. V.R. Rudani | (1989) 2 SCC 691 | Mandamus may be issued against non-statutory bodies if public duty exists | Followed to explain scope of Mandamus |
| Comptroller & Auditor General v. Jagannathan | (1986) 2 SCC 679 | Article 226 empowers High Courts to ensure public duties are fairly exercised | Reiterated for Mandamus scope |
| Sarvesh Refractories (P) Ltd. v. CCE | (2007) 13 SCC 601 | Classification dispute must be resolved by the jurisdictional officer of the supplier | Followed to hold purchaser has no jurisdiction |
| Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. v. Dewan Chand Ram Saran | (2012) 21 taxmann.com 20 (SC) | Parties can agree on who bears service tax liability in contracts | Cited to uphold contractual freedom |
| Michigan Rubber v. State of Karnataka | (2012) 8 SCC 216 | Courts can’t interfere in tender terms unless arbitrary, mala fide, or irrational | Applied to restrict judicial review |
| Global Energy Ltd. v. Adani Exports Ltd. | (2005) 4 SCC 435 | Tender terms are beyond judicial scrutiny unless patently unreasonable | Relied upon to support appeal |
| Hochtief Gammon v. State of Orissa | (1975) 2 SCC 649 | Judicial review not restricted to prerogative writs; can ensure justice under Article 226 | Cited in Mandamus context |




