Case Title: R.P. Techsoft International Pvt. Ltd. vs Deputy Commissioner of Revenue (SGST Officer) and Ors.
Court: Calcutta High Court (Division Bench)
Petition No.: MAT/969/2025 with IA No. CAN/1/2025
Date of Judgment: 23 July 2025
Category: Transitional Credit / Input Tax Credit
Relevant Sections: Section 140 of the CGST Act, 2017; Article 226 of the Constitution of India
Relevant Circular: CBIC Guideline dated 10 November 2022 issued pursuant to Union of India v. Filco Trade Centre Pvt. Ltd., SLP(C) Nos. 32709–32710 of 2018
Facts (Para 1–2)
R.P. Techsoft International Pvt. Ltd. filed a writ before the Calcutta High Court challenging an order dated 27 February 2023 by the Deputy Commissioner of Revenue, Salt Lake Charge, denying transitional credit under GST. The Single Bench dismissed the petition citing the availability of an alternate appellate remedy. The petitioner appealed under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent, asserting violation of principles of natural justice and wrongful reliance on the Central Tax Authority’s verification report without independent application of mind.
Questions (Para 3–4)
The principal issue before the Division Bench was whether the State Tax Authority, while deciding admissibility of transitional credit, could treat the verification report of the Central Tax Authority as binding or whether it was required to independently adjudicate in accordance with the CBIC Circular dated 10 November 2022, clauses 5.3.5–5.3.8, read with the directions in Filco Trade Centre Pvt. Ltd.
Observations (Para 4–6)
The Court reiterated that though an alternate statutory remedy exists, the High Court can exercise writ jurisdiction where there is lack of jurisdiction or breach of natural justice. Examining CBIC’s circular clauses 5.3.5–5.3.8, the Bench noted that the jurisdictional officer (State Tax Authority) must provide the assessee a copy of the verification report, invite objections, allow a personal hearing, and then pass a reasoned order independently.
However, the Deputy Commissioner merely accepted the Central officer’s report as binding without addressing the assessee’s written rebuttal dated 24 February 2023. This failure constituted a breach of both the CBIC guideline and the principles of natural justice. The guideline expressly required the State Authority to exercise independent judgment, and any contrary reading would render clause 5.3.7 redundant.
Judgment (Para 6–8)
The Division Bench (T.S. Sivagnanam CJ and Chaitali Chatterjee J) held that the impugned order dated 27 February 2023 was violative of natural justice and contrary to the CBIC guideline. Accordingly, both the single bench order dated 9 June 2025 and the Deputy Commissioner’s order were set aside.
The matter was remanded to the State Tax Authority to conduct a fresh adjudication by:
-
considering clauses 5.3.5 to 5.3.8 of the CBIC guideline;
-
granting a fresh opportunity of personal hearing;
-
examining all written and oral submissions and judicial precedents; and
-
passing a speaking order on merits within two months.
No costs were awarded.
Summary of Referred Case
| Case Name | Court & Citation | Key Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Union of India v. Filco Trade Centre Pvt. Ltd. (SLP (C) Nos. 32709–32710 of 2018) | Supreme Court of India | Directed reopening of TRAN-1/TRAN-2 portal to enable eligible taxpayers to claim transitional credit and mandated verification as per CBIC guidelines of 10 Nov 2022. |
Between Fine Lines
The ruling underscores that State GST officers cannot merely rubber-stamp the Central GST verification report in transitional credit matters. Independent evaluation, observance of procedural fairness, and issuance of a speaking order are mandatory. For trade, it reaffirms that denial of credit without proper reasoning or hearing is unsustainable, and writ jurisdiction remains available despite appellate alternatives when natural justice is breached.
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




