Home Case Laws Writ petition dismissed as ITC claim based on fake invoices was unsupported...

Writ petition dismissed as ITC claim based on fake invoices was unsupported by evidence and petitioner failed to discharge onus of proving genuine transactions

0
363

Case Title: Roshan Sharma v. Deputy Commissioner of Revenue & Anr.
Court: High Court at Calcutta (Appellate Side – Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
Petition No.: WPA 27101 of 2024 with CAN 1 of 2025
Date of Judgment: 18 July 2025
Category: Input Tax Credit (Fake Invoices / Denial of ITC)
Relevant Sections: Sections 16, 29(2)(e), 86A of the CGST/WBGST Act 2017

Facts of the Case (Paras 1–7)

Roshan Sharma, a registered GST dealer trading in metals under M/s ARS Metals, availed and utilized Input Tax Credit (ITC) for FY 2020-21 to 2022-23. During scrutiny, the department found that ITC was claimed on supplies from M/s Rachna Trading Co., whose proprietor – Shyam Sundar Tiwari – had a registration cancelled ab initio under Section 29(2)(e). The supplier was found non-existent, and the invoices and e-way bills were alleged to be fake.

In the first round of litigation (WPA 8390 of 2024), the High Court Division Bench remanded the matter directing the proper officer to provide copies of statements of Tiwari and transporter Ashoke Kumar Saha and to permit cross-examination. On remand, the officer furnished documents, including statements, complaint copies, and vehicle owner declarations, and allowed cross-examination. However, the petitioner’s representative refused to participate in the re-examination of Tiwari and did not sign the note-sheet.

The adjudication order dated 24 July 2024 confirmed the tax demand. Instead of appealing under Section 107 of the Act, the petitioner filed a fresh writ on 11 November 2024 alleging denial of fair opportunity.


Questions before the Court (Paras 8–10)

  1. Whether the adjudication order violated natural justice by denying full cross-examination of witnesses relied upon by the department.

  2. Whether the proper officer was bound to obtain and furnish toll-plaza records of transport vehicles to verify genuineness of supply.

  3. Whether the writ petition was maintainable despite availability of an appellate remedy.


Court’s Observations (Paras 11–15)

The Court noted that the petitioner was supplied with all documents and permitted to cross-examine both Tiwari and Saha. The petitioner voluntarily refused to attend re-examination, thus forfeiting further rights. The adjudicating officer had considered all materials and given detailed findings.

The Court held that under Section 16 of the CGST Act, the burden of proving eligibility to ITC lies upon the taxpayer. The petitioner could not shift this obligation onto the department by insisting that toll-plaza records be produced by the officer.

The reliance on Granules India Ltd. v. Union of India (2021) 20 SCC 419 and Popatrao Vyankatrao Patil v. State of Maharashtra (2020) 19 SCC 241 was found misplaced since those cases pertained to Customs and tender disputes respectively.

The Court reiterated that no jurisdictional error or perversity was demonstrated, and the petitioner bypassed the statutory appellate route under Section 107.


Judgment (Paras 15–17)

The writ petition and connected application (CAN 1 of 2025) were dismissed. The Court held that the petitioner failed to substantiate the genuineness of transactions and did not discharge the evidentiary burden. No costs were awarded.


Summary of Cases Referred

Case Citation / Context Held / Relevance
Granules India Ltd. v. Union of India (2021) 20 SCC 419 – Customs context State must act fairly, but facts distinguishable; not applicable to GST ITC disputes.
Popatrao Vyankatrao Patil v. State of Maharashtra (2020) 19 SCC 241 – Tender refund case State to act as model litigant; unrelated to ITC adjudication.

Between Fine Lines

For GST dealers, this judgment reinforces that onus to prove the genuineness of ITC lies squarely on the taxpayer. If the supplier or transporter is found fake or non-existent, the purchaser must produce corroborative transport and payment evidence such as toll data, e-way bills, and bank records. Mere procedural complaints like denial of cross-examination cannot rescue a case if substantive evidence is lacking. Writ petitions cannot substitute the statutory appeal process under Section 107 of the CGST Act.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY