Case Title: S.N. Trading Company & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors.
Court: High Court of Judicature at Calcutta (Circuit Bench at Jalpaiguri)
Petition No.: M.A.T. 48 of 2025 with I.A. No. CAN 1 of 2025
Date of Judgment: 26 June 2025
Category: Detention and Release of Goods and Conveyance under Section 129 of CGST Act
Relevant Sections: Section 129(1)(a), Section 129(3), Section 129(6) of CGST Act, Section 20 of IGST Act
Facts (Paras 1–4):
The appellants, S.N. Trading Company, were transporting areca nuts in vehicle UP14HT 7566, which was intercepted on 16 May 2025 in Jalpaiguri district. The goods were detained under Section 129(3) of the CGST Act on grounds of (i) a 420 kg discrepancy in weight, (ii) absence of a bill of supply or tax invoice, and (iii) non-production of any proof of payment. The adjudicating authority imposed penalty under Section 20 of the IGST Act read with Section 129(1)(a) and Section 129(6) of the CGST Act amounting to ₹2 lakh, both on the goods and the vehicle.
Questions Before the Court (Paras 5–7):
Whether the learned Single Bench was justified in dismissing the writ petition on grounds of availability of alternate remedy and whether interim relief could be granted considering that the detained goods were perishable and the vehicle subject to deterioration.
Observations (Paras 7–10):
The Division Bench agreed with the Single Judge that the writ petition should not be entertained when a statutory appeal under the GST Act was available. The case involved disputed questions of fact such as weighment accuracy and documentation. However, the Court took note of two practical concerns —
(a) if the vehicle remained detained, it would deteriorate, and
(b) as areca nuts are perishable, their detention would render them valueless.
Hence, while upholding the Single Bench’s decision, the Court exercised equitable jurisdiction to prevent economic waste and ensure procedural fairness.
Judgment (Paras 10–15):
The Division Bench dismissed the appeal but permitted relief:
-
The appellants may file a statutory appeal within 15 days.
-
The Department shall sell the areca nuts by public auction within 45 days, allowing the appellants to participate.
-
Sale proceeds shall be kept in an interest-bearing account pending the appellate decision.
-
The vehicle shall be released upon payment of ₹50,000 and a bond of ₹1.5 lakh, subject to the outcome of appeal.
-
The department must release the vehicle within seven days of payment and bond submission.
Between Fine Lines (Trade/Industry Takeaway):
The judgment reinforces that High Courts will not entertain GST detention challenges under Section 129 if alternate appellate remedies exist, yet equitable relief can be granted to prevent commercial hardship. Businesses must promptly file appeals while seeking limited relief for perishable or depreciating assets. Detention orders should be handled strategically to safeguard property without compromising procedural compliance.
Summary of Cases Referred
| Sr. No. | Case Name | Citation / Year | Verdict Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | S.N. Trading Company v. Union of India | 2025 (High Court of Calcutta, Jalpaiguri Bench) | Writ petition dismissed due to alternate remedy; Court directed auction of perishable goods and conditional release of vehicle to avoid deterioration pending appeal. |
Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”




