Home Case Laws Writ petition dismissed as High Court held that disputed second GST registration...

Writ petition dismissed as High Court held that disputed second GST registration and penalties cannot be quashed under writ jurisdiction due to contradictory claims and limitation, leaving remedy of appeal under Section 107 of CGST Act

0
260

Case Summary

Case Title: Laxmi Hari Collection v. Additional Commissioner, Delhi-West, CGST Department
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition No.: W.P.(C) 11092/2025 & CM APPL. 45640/2025
Date of Judgement: 29th July 2025
Category of Dispute: Penalty – fraudulent ITC, misuse of GSTIN
Relevant Sections: Section 122(1)(ii), 122(1)(vii), 122(1)(x), (xii), (xvi), (xvii), Section 70, Section 107 of the CGST Act, 2017 read with Delhi GST Act and Section 20 of the IGST Act, 2017.

Facts (Para 2–7)

The petitioner, Laxmi Hari Collection, challenged the Order-in-Original dated 30.01.2025 imposing penalties exceeding ₹2.9 crores under Section 122 of the CGST Act on account of fraudulent ITC under a second GSTIN. The petitioner argued that only one GSTIN was used, while the second GSTIN (07BDGPS9274J2ZS) was misused by unknown persons. Upon receiving the first demand notice in 2019, the petitioner lodged an FIR and informed the department to block the registration. Summons under Section 70 were later issued in 2023, followed by a SCN dated 30.04.2023 and the impugned penalty order. The petitioner contended he was illiterate, unaware of the second GSTIN, and acted promptly by filing a police complaint.


Questions before Court

  1. Whether penalties under Section 122 of the CGST Act could be sustained when the petitioner denied using the disputed GSTIN.

  2. Whether writ jurisdiction could be invoked to quash the penalties when appellate remedy under Section 107 was available.

  3. Whether the delay in challenging the Order-in-Original barred writ interference.


Observations (Para 9–14)

The Court noted contradictions in the petitioner’s stance:

  • E-mails in July 2017 showed both GSTINs were communicated to the petitioner’s registered contact details, suggesting awareness.

  • Petitioner’s 2019 complaint letter admitted to mistakenly applying for two GST registrations.

  • Aadhaar authentication linked to another e-mail/mobile was highlighted, but the evidence remained contradictory.

  • No meaningful follow-up was pursued after the FIR/complaint, showing lack of seriousness.

The Court expressed concern that the petitioner acted casually, neither contesting the Order-in-Original in time nor ensuring proper investigation of the alleged misuse. Since limitation under Section 107 had expired, writ jurisdiction could not substitute for factual inquiry.


Judgement (Para 15–16)

The Delhi High Court held that the case involved disputed facts and contradictions unsuitable for writ adjudication. It dismissed the petition but granted liberty to the petitioner to file an appeal under Section 107 of CGST Act by 31st August 2025, subject to pre-deposit requirements.


Table of Earlier Cases Referred

(No external precedents discussed in this judgement; only statutory provisions relied upon.)


Between Fine Lines

This ruling underscores that traders must carefully monitor GST registrations linked to their PAN. Casual complaints without sustained follow-up will not protect them from liability. If fraudulent use of GSTIN is alleged, timely action including FIR follow-up and appeal under Section 107 is vital. Writ petitions will not rescue taxpayers when alternate remedies and statutory timelines are ignored.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY