Home Case Laws Appeal allowed to be maintained with 10% pre-deposit as Tribunal yet unconstituted;...

Appeal allowed to be maintained with 10% pre-deposit as Tribunal yet unconstituted; High Court aligns State’s requirement with Central notification reducing deposit from 20% to 10%.

0
240

Case Title: Rajesh Swain v. Joint Commissioner of State Tax (Appeal), CT & GST, Sambalpur & Others
Court: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Petition No.: W.P.(C) No. 69 of 2025
Category: Appeal before Appellate Tribunal – Pre-deposit requirement
Date of Judgment: 08 January 2025
Relevant Sections: Section 112 of the CGST Act, 2017 (Appeals to Appellate Tribunal), Section 107 (Appeal to Appellate Authority), Rule 108 of CGST Rules, 2017


Facts (Paras 1–3):

The petitioner, Rajesh Swain, challenged the order dated 16 September 2023 passed by the First Appellate Authority under the Odisha GST regime. He intended to file a second appeal before the Appellate Tribunal, but the Tribunal had not yet been constituted. Consequently, as per the earlier order dated 16 February 2024 in M/s Maa Tarini Traders v. State of Odisha [WP(C) No. 42015 of 2023], the High Court had directed that such appellants could file writ petitions and obtain stay upon depositing 10% of the disputed tax at the time of filing appeal, and an additional 20% of the remaining disputed tax amount.

However, the petitioner argued that a Central Notification dated 16 August 2024 had reduced the additional pre-deposit requirement from 20% to 10%, and that the State of Odisha issued a corresponding notification on 29 October 2024. He requested the Court to dispose of the matter in line with the updated notification and prior judicial directions.


Questions Before the Court (Paras 1–3):

  1. Whether the petitioner could seek appellate relief when the GST Appellate Tribunal was yet to be constituted.

  2. Whether the State’s pre-deposit requirement for stay of demand should stand reduced to 10% of the remaining disputed tax, in light of the Central Government’s corresponding notification.


Observations (Paras 4–5):

The Court took note that the petitioner had acted in accordance with the precedent set in Maa Tarini Traders and that the State had now harmonized its pre-deposit condition with the Central notification. The Bench observed that there was no reason to insist on a higher deposit (20%) when both the Central and State Governments had officially reduced it to 10%.

The Court thus accepted the submission made on behalf of the petitioner, emphasizing uniformity in fiscal administration and avoidance of undue financial burden on taxpayers, especially when the appellate mechanism under Section 112 was not operational.


Judgment (Para 6):

The High Court disposed of the writ petition by allowing the petitioner to obtain stay of the impugned first appellate order upon making a 10% deposit of the disputed tax as per the revised notification. This effectively aligned State GST procedures with Central GST norms.

(Coram: Justice Arindam Sinha & Justice M.S. Sahoo)


Summary of Cases Referred

Case Name Court Citation/No. Key Verdict / Principle
M/s Maa Tarini Traders v. State of Odisha & Ors. Orissa High Court WP(C) No. 42015 of 2023 (Order dated 16.02.2024) Permitted filing of writs during non-constitution of Appellate Tribunal; stay of recovery upon 10% + 20% pre-deposit.

Between Fine Lines (Practical Takeaway):

Taxpayers in Odisha awaiting GST Tribunal constitution can seek interim protection from recovery by depositing 10% of the disputed tax, instead of 30%, aligning State and Central GST frameworks. The decision reinforces parity between State and Central policies and relieves assessees from additional cash flow stress during appellate delays.

Disclaimer – “The above summary is for academic purpose only; not formal legal opinion. Seek professional opinion before application. Author or publisher or website shall not be responsible for any usage in any form.”

LEAVE A REPLY