Case Title: G.S. Industries v. Commissioner of Central Tax and GST, Delhi (West)
Court: High Court of Delhi
Petition Number: W.P.(C) No. 13149 of 2024
Date of Judgment: 16 December 2024
Relevant Sections: Section 107(2), 107(12), Rule 90(3) of the CGST Act and Rules, Circular Nos. 125/44/2019-GST & 135/05/2020-GST
Category of Dispute: Refund – Inverted Duty Structure
Facts of the Case
[Para 2–4] G.S. Industries filed refund applications for ITC on account of inverted duty structure for FY 2018–19 on 04.07.2019 and 09.07.2019. Deficiency memos were addressed, but the refund remained pending.
[Para 5–6] A writ petition in 2020 led to a direction for early disposal, yet refund was rejected on 14.12.2020. Appeals against the rejection succeeded on 03.01.2022.
[Para 7] The Appellate Authority accepted the refund claim noting lack of grounds for rejection (e.g., existence proved, brass usage adequately explained), finding the adjudication unsustainable.
[Para 8–9] Despite the favourable order, refund was delayed, prompting a second writ petition. The Court on 28.03.2023 directed immediate processing. Refund was finally sanctioned on 09.06.2023.
[Para 10–11] Interest on refund was denied, and that separate issue is under challenge in another writ petition.
[Para 12–14] Meanwhile, the Department reviewed the refund order on 11.12.2023 under Section 107(2) citing non-submission of Annexure-B, and the refund was reversed by Order-in-Appeal dated 24.05.2024.
[Para 15–18] The High Court quashed this order, holding the Commissioner cannot review an order passed to implement a binding Appellate Order.
Questions in Consideration
- Whether the refund sanctioned vide order dated 09.06.2023 could be reviewed and reversed by the Commissioner under Section 107(2) of the CGST Act. [Para 16]
- Whether such review is valid when the original refund was sanctioned in compliance with a prior Order-in-Appeal, which attained finality. [Para 15–17]
Observations of the Court
[Para 15] The Court reaffirmed its earlier ruling dated 28.03.2023 that the refund cannot be denied if no appeal is filed against the Order-in-Appeal dated 03.01.2022.
[Para 16–17] It was held that Section 107(2) permits the Commissioner to review orders of an adjudicating authority—not those implementing an Appellate Authority’s order. Hence, review of the refund order (dated 09.06.2023) was ultra vires.
[Para 17] The act of setting aside the refund order, without disturbing the appellate order, was unsustainable and amounted to indirectly circumventing a final and binding order.
Judgment of the Court
[Para 18] The High Court allowed the writ petition and quashed the Department’s Order-in-Appeal dated 24.05.2024. The denial of interest, however, was left open for adjudication in separate proceedings.
Between Fine Lines
- Once an appellate order attains finality, refund must be processed accordingly.
- A Commissioner cannot review or override such final orders under Section 107(2).
- Procedural objections (e.g., Annexure-B) cannot defeat substantive rights affirmed by appellate forums.
- Refund once granted pursuant to a binding order cannot be reversed indirectly.
- Separate remedy for interest remains open but not addressed in this decision.
Summary of Referred Cases
| S.No | Name of Case | Citation | Summary | Verdict |
| 1 | G.S. Industries v. Pr. Commissioner CGST | W.P.(C) 9321/2020, order dated 24.11.2020 | Court directed decision on refund within 3 weeks | Petitioner succeeded |
| 2 | G.S. Industries v. Commissioner CGST | W.P.(C) 14719/2022; [2023] 151 taxmann.com 162/98 GST 668/75 G.S.T.L. 309 (Delhi) | Refund cannot be denied when appellate order not stayed or appealed | Petition allowed |
| 3 | Brij Mohan Mangla v. Union of India | W.P.(C) 14234/2022; order dated 23.02.2023 | Reaffirmed that refund cannot be withheld merely because department intends to file an appeal | Relief granted to petitioner |
Takeaway for the Case
“Appellate Authority’s Order Cannot Be Overturned by Commissioner Through Backdoor Review.”




