Cipla Limited, a pharmaceutical company having industrial units in Sikkim, approached the Sikkim High Court challenging an order relating to its claim for budgetary support under the Budgetary Support Scheme introduced after implementation of GST for eligible units situated in Jammu & Kashmir, Uttarakhand, Himachal Pradesh and the North Eastern States, including Sikkim.
The petitioner had submitted a declaration/application on 19 September 2019 claiming Input Tax Credit of ₹15,28,80,613 for its eligible unit. At the direction of the GST authorities, Cipla subsequently furnished a Chartered Accountant’s certificate recording that the ITC actually availed in respect of the eligible unit was ₹10,01,57,759.
According to Cipla, the higher figure mentioned in the original declaration was a mistake. As a consequence of relying upon that figure, an amount of ₹5,27,22,856 was allegedly deducted from the budgetary support otherwise available to the company. The grievance was that the authorities concluded the proceedings without considering the CA certificate or giving Cipla a proper opportunity to explain the discrepancy.
Issue Before the High Court
The principal issue was whether the authorities could reject or disregard the petitioner’s explanation concerning an apparent error in the declaration merely because the Budgetary Support Scheme did not contain a specific provision permitting post-facto revision or substitution of figures.
The Court also examined whether the proceedings could validly be concluded when a material discrepancy between the declaration and the CA certificate was apparent on the record but the petitioner had not been afforded a meaningful opportunity to explain it.
High Court’s Findings
The Sikkim High Court held that the matter was not merely one of statutory “rectification” after completion of proceedings. The defect went to the decision-making process itself because the authorities had concluded the proceedings without permitting Cipla to explain the discrepancy between its declaration and the CA certificate.
The Court observed that the CA certificate had been furnished pursuant to the authorities’ own direction. Once the certificate disclosed figures different from those appearing in the declaration, fairness required the concerned officer to seek an explanation from the petitioner before deciding the claim.
The Court further held that although an applicant would ordinarily be expected to stand by the declaration submitted by it, such a principle cannot operate as an inflexible rule. Where the applicant asserts that the declaration contains a genuine error or mistake, it must be given an opportunity to explain how the mistake occurred and, where necessary, substantiate the explanation through supporting documents.
Significantly, the Court observed that a mere human error in a declaration cannot be capitalised upon to the prejudice of the claimant without first affording an opportunity to explain the error.
The High Court emphasised that administrative authorities are required to act fairly. Where a discrepancy is apparent on the face of the record and forms the basis of the proposed decision, the affected party must receive a reasonable opportunity to explain it before an adverse conclusion is reached.
No Final Finding on Cipla’s Entitlement
The High Court did not hold that Cipla’s explanation regarding the ITC figures was necessarily correct.
It expressly refrained from deciding whether the discrepancy was actually the result of an error or whether Cipla’s explanation should ultimately be accepted. The Court confined its ruling to the procedural requirement that Cipla must first be afforded a fair opportunity to explain and substantiate the discrepancy.
Decision
The High Court set aside the impugned order to the extent challenged by Cipla.
Cipla was granted liberty to produce all documents necessary to substantiate its contention that an error had occurred in the declaration. Respondent Nos. 5 and 6 were directed to undertake the required exercise and complete it within eight weeks.
Accordingly, WP(C) No. 38 of 2023 was allowed to the extent indicated by the Court.
Key Takeaway
The judgment reinforces the principle that procedural fairness applies even where a statutory scheme does not expressly provide a mechanism for revising a declaration. Where the records themselves disclose a material inconsistency, the authority cannot mechanically rely upon one document and ignore another relevant document without first permitting the claimant to explain the discrepancy.
The ruling is particularly relevant for GST-linked incentive and budgetary support proceedings where clerical or human errors in declarations may materially affect the quantum of benefits. The Court has clarified, however, that granting an opportunity to explain an error does not automatically establish the claimant’s substantive entitlement; the explanation and supporting material may still be examined on merits.




